Sydney apartment tower with water staining beneath concrete balconies

Building & Construction Litigation

Strata Building Defects & Owners Corporation Disputes

In this practice area

Owners corporation claims for defective common property against builders, developers and practitioners, together with section 106 maintenance and damages disputes, from building reports and approvals through NCAT and the Supreme Court.

01

When the building itself becomes the dispute

Water through a podium slab, a balcony membrane that has failed across several levels, cracking in a transfer structure or cladding that does not meet fire safety requirements: in a strata scheme, these are rarely isolated repairs. They affect every lot owner, the scheme's capital works planning, its insurance and, often, the value of each apartment. The owners corporation must decide whether to repair, whom to pursue and how to fund both, frequently while owners are already in dispute with one another.

The first legal question is classification. Common property is ordinarily the responsibility of the owners corporation, and defects in it are ordinarily pursued by the owners corporation. Lot property is ordinarily the owner's concern. The boundary is set by the registered strata plan and the applicable statutory rules, not by where the damage appears. Water entering an apartment frequently originates in common property membranes, slabs or façade elements, and that distinction decides who has the claim and who carries the duty to repair.

The second question is time. Statutory warranty periods, the Part 4 duty under the Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020 (NSW) and the ten year long stop for building actions run on different starting points and different rules. A scheme that waits for every investigation to be finished before taking advice can find that the most valuable claim has expired.

03

The statutory duty of care: builders, developers and others in control

Part 4 of the Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020 (NSW) imposes a duty on every person who carries out construction work to exercise reasonable care to avoid economic loss caused by defects. The duty is owed to each owner and each subsequent owner of the land, and section 38 addresses the loss an owners corporation suffers, including the cost of rectifying common property. Construction work includes building work, preparing designs, supplying building products, and supervising, coordinating, project managing or otherwise having substantive control over that work.

Part 4 matters because it reaches beyond the contracting builder. A developer, a design practitioner or another participant may owe the duty if what it actually did falls within the definition. Title alone does not decide the question; the evidence of who controlled what does. The duty cannot be delegated, cannot be contracted out of and operates in addition to the statutory warranties. It is a duty of reasonable care rather than a guarantee that no defects will occur, so the claim must identify the risk and the precautions that should have been taken.

In Pafburn Pty Ltd v The Owners – Strata Plan No 84674 [2024] HCA 49, the High Court held that a builder and developer could not use proportionate liability to shift responsibility to others whose work fell within their non-delegable duty. For owners corporations, that can significantly improve the prospects of recovering the whole loss from a solvent defendant. The retrospective operation of Part 4 extends to loss that first became apparent in the ten years before 10 June 2020, but every claim remains subject to the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW) and to the ten year long stop for building actions in section 6.20 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW).

04

Waterproofing, façade and structural defects

Waterproofing failures are the most common source of strata defect litigation and among the most contested. Balconies, planter boxes, podium and roof membranes, wet areas, window and door junctions and basement walls each raise different questions about design, installation sequence, falls and drainage, product selection and later maintenance. A respondent will often argue that the damage results from owner renovations, blocked drains or a failure to maintain. The investigation should be scoped to answer those arguments rather than simply catalogue leaks.

Façade defects raise their own problems: cracked render and masonry, failed sealant and flashing, corroded fixings, defective glazing and cladding that does not comply with fire safety requirements. Structural defects, including cracking in slabs, transfer beams and columns, excessive deflection and concrete spalling, usually require an engineer's assessment of cause before any responsible party can be identified. Where the defect involves fire safety or structural adequacy, the owners corporation may also face regulatory or safety obligations that cannot wait for litigation.

In each case, the evidence must eventually show what the defect is, why it is a defect against the contract, the Building Code or the relevant standard, what caused it, and what rectification is reasonable. Destructive testing, sampling and photographic records made before repairs begin can be decisive. Rectification works completed without a proper record can leave a scheme unable to prove the very defect it paid to fix.

05

The strata building bond and inspections scheme

For qualifying residential strata buildings, Part 11 of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW) requires the developer, unless an exemption applies, to lodge a building bond of two per cent of the contract price before applying for an occupation certificate. The scheme is administered by Building Commission NSW. An independent building inspector prepares an interim report, ordinarily 15 to 18 months after completion, and a final report towards the end of the second year identifying defects that remain unrectified. An increase in the bond to three per cent has been deferred until 1 July 2028.

The reports are valuable evidence and an early point of leverage, but they are not a complete statement of the scheme's rights. The bond is security for the rectification of identified defects; it is not a cap on the developer's or builder's liability, and it does not replace a damages claim. For work covered by the bond scheme, the Home Building Act contains a specific extension of the two year warranty period linked to the final inspection report, and the dates should be checked as soon as the interim report is received. The owners corporation should engage with the inspection process, record its own observations and preserve its rights against every responsible party at the same time.

06

Section 106 claims: the owners corporation's own duty

Section 106 of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW) requires an owners corporation to properly maintain and keep in a state of good and serviceable repair the common property, and to renew or replace common property fixtures and fittings. The duty has been treated as strict rather than a duty to take reasonable care. The owners corporation may decide by special resolution not to repair a particular item only where repair is inappropriate and the decision will not affect safety or detract from the appearance of the scheme. It may defer work while pursuing others responsible for the damage, but only where deferral will not affect safety or a person's access to or use of the common property or a lot.

A lot owner may recover from the owners corporation, as damages for breach of statutory duty, any reasonably foreseeable loss caused by a contravention. That can include damage to the owner's property, lost rent and alternative accommodation. The current provision allows an action to be brought within six years after the owner first becomes aware of the loss, and the effect of that change on older claims should be checked. In Vickery v The Owners – Strata Plan No 80412 [2020] NSWCA 284, the Court of Appeal held that NCAT can award those damages through its order making power in section 232.

An owners corporation can therefore be a claimant against the builder and a respondent to its own owners at the same time, about the same water. Those positions must be managed together. Admissions made to an owner, the timing of repairs and decisions to defer work all affect both claims. For lot owners, a section 106 claim may be the most direct route to recovering loss caused by defective common property, and it does not depend on the outcome of the scheme's case against the builder.

07

Approvals, funding, forum and the conduct of proceedings

Section 103 of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW) requires a resolution at a general meeting before an owners corporation obtains legal services requiring payment, approving the services either with unlimited costs or up to a maximum amount. There are exceptions, including advice before commencing legal action, urgent services up to the prescribed limit and the recovery of unpaid levies. A failure to obtain approval does not invalidate the proceedings, but it can expose the committee and fuel disputes among owners. Costs disclosures must be provided to owners and committee members under section 105, and section 104 affects how the costs of proceedings against owners can be funded.

Defect claims are usually funded through levies, so the motion, the budget and the explanation given to owners need care. Owners will reasonably ask about prospects, cost, duration and the risk of an adverse costs order. The legal advice should be capable of being explained at a general meeting without waiving privilege over the detailed assessment.

Building claims within the Home Building Act may be brought in NCAT, which has a monetary limit of $500,000 for those claims under section 48K. Larger and more complex claims, and claims under Part 4 of the Design and Building Practitioners Act, are commonly brought in the Supreme Court of NSW, where the Technology and Construction List is directed to construction disputes. Strata disputes about the owners corporation's own functions usually go to NCAT, generally after mediation under section 227. Separately, Building Commission NSW holds powers under the Residential Apartment Buildings (Compliance and Enforcement Powers) Act 2020 (NSW), including building work rectification orders. Those powers do not give owners a private cause of action, but the regulator's engagement can influence the response of a developer.

08

How we act for owners corporations and strata managers

We act for owners corporations, strata committees and strata managing agents in defect claims against builders, developers and building practitioners, and in section 106 disputes. We begin with the strata plan, the completion and occupation certificate dates, the bond reports and the existing expert material, and we give the committee a clear view of the claims available, the limitation position and the approvals needed.

From there, we instruct and coordinate the building consultant, engineers and quantity surveyor so that their evidence answers the legal questions, prepare the proceedings in NCAT or the Supreme Court, and conduct negotiation, mediation and hearings. Each matter has direct partner involvement. Where a responsible party is insolvent, insured or has commenced proceedings of its own, we assess the effect on recovery before the scheme commits further funds.

Frequently asked questions

Strata Building Defects & Owners Corporation Disputes

Can an owners corporation sue the developer as well as the builder?

Often, yes. The Home Building Act gives an immediate successor in title warranties as if the developer had contracted with it, and work done on behalf of a developer is taken to be done by the developer. A developer may also owe the statutory duty of care under Part 4 of the Design and Building Practitioners Act if it had substantive control over the work. The available claims depend on the evidence and the dates.

How long does an owners corporation have to bring a defect claim?

Under the Home Building Act, generally six years from completion for a breach resulting in a major defect and two years for other defects, with specific rules for the completion of new strata buildings and an extension for bonded work. Part 4 claims are subject to the Limitation Act and the ten year long stop for building actions. The periods run differently, so the position should be checked early.

Does the building bond limit what the scheme can recover?

No. The bond is security for the rectification of defects identified through the inspection scheme. It does not cap the developer's or builder's liability and does not replace a claim for damages or rectification costs.

Is waterproofing failure always a major defect?

Not automatically. Waterproofing is a major element, but the defect must also cause, or be likely to cause, one of the serious consequences the Act describes. Expert evidence about the extent and effect of the failure is usually needed to establish the classification.

Does the owners corporation need a general meeting resolution before suing?

Section 103 requires a general meeting resolution before the owners corporation obtains legal services requiring payment, subject to exceptions such as advice before commencing proceedings and urgent services up to the prescribed limit. Failure to obtain approval does not invalidate the proceedings, but approval should be obtained properly.

Can a lot owner recover losses from the owners corporation for leaking common property?

Yes, if the owners corporation has breached its duty under section 106 to maintain and repair common property. The owner may recover reasonably foreseeable loss as damages, and NCAT can make that award. The claim must be brought within six years after the owner first becomes aware of the loss.