Residential towers under construction overlooking Sydney Harbour

Building & Construction Litigation

Builder, Developer & Contractor Litigation

In this practice area

Representation of builders, developers, head contractors and subcontractors in defect claims, cross-claims down the contractual chain, regulatory orders and disputes between project participants.

01

Acting for those who build

Builders, developers and contractors face claims from many directions at once: owners corporations and purchasers alleging defects, principals claiming liquidated damages, subcontractors pursuing payment and regulators issuing orders. A single building can produce litigation in NCAT, the Supreme Court and adjudication simultaneously, with the same facts examined in each forum.

We act for builders, developers, head contractors and subcontractors as claimants and respondents. Our work concerns the defence and resolution of defect claims, the pursuit of cross-claims against those responsible, disputes between developers and their builders, and the regulatory processes that increasingly accompany residential construction in NSW.

03

Developers, the statutory duty and non-delegable responsibility

Developers face exposure under the Home Building Act, because work done on behalf of a developer is taken to be done by the developer, and potentially under Part 4 of the Design and Building Practitioners Act where the developer had substantive control over the construction work. Whether a developer had that control depends on the evidence of what it actually did, not on its title. Individuals who exercised that control may also be exposed.

Following Pafburn Pty Ltd v The Owners – Strata Plan No 84674 [2024] HCA 49, a builder or developer owing the non-delegable duty cannot reduce its liability under the proportionate liability provisions by pointing to others whose work fell within its responsibility. The practical consequence is that the right to recover from subcontractors and consultants now depends more heavily on cross-claims, contractual indemnities and insurance.

04

Cross-claims down the contractual chain

A builder sued for defective waterproofing, façade or structural work will usually seek to pass that liability to the subcontractors and designers responsible. Cross-claims must be brought within time, against the right entities, under the right contractual and statutory provisions, and supported by expert evidence that is consistent with the builder's defence of the primary claim.

Subcontracts often contain indemnities, defect obligations, notice requirements and limitations of liability that must be followed. Insurance is critical: subcontractors' public liability and professional indemnity policies, and the builder's own cover, may respond in different ways. Notification of claims and circumstances should not wait for the primary proceedings to be served.

05

Regulatory orders and residential apartment buildings

For residential apartment buildings, the Residential Apartment Buildings (Compliance and Enforcement Powers) Act 2020 (NSW) requires an expected completion notice, generally six to 12 months before an occupation certificate is applied for, and permits prohibition orders preventing the issue of an occupation certificate or the registration of a strata plan, stop work orders and building work rectification orders. Those powers are administered through Building Commission NSW.

Orders can halt settlements, affect financing and create obligations that run alongside private litigation. A response to a proposed order should address the technical issues, the procedural requirements and the commercial consequences together, and should be consistent with the position the developer or builder takes in any defect proceedings.

06

Disputes between developers, builders and contractors

Disputes between project participants often concern payment, variations, delay and termination, together with the allocation of responsibility for defects claimed by purchasers or an owners corporation. A developer may hold a builder responsible for defects while the builder pursues the developer for its final account; each claim affects the other, and both may involve security, liquidated damages and statutory adjudication.

Insolvency frequently shapes the outcome. A builder in liquidation cannot use the security of payment regime to enforce claims, home building compensation cover may respond only in specified circumstances, and claims against directors or related entities require careful analysis. We work with our Debt Recovery & Insolvency practice where these issues arise.

Frequently asked questions

Builder, Developer & Contractor Litigation

Can a builder insist on rectifying defects rather than paying damages?

For residential building work, a court or tribunal must have regard to rectification by the responsible party as the preferred outcome, but it is not an absolute right. The builder's capacity, the state of the relationship and the owner's conduct all affect whether a work order is made.

Is a developer liable for defects if it did not build the project?

It may be. Under the Home Building Act, work done on behalf of a developer is taken to have been done by the developer. A developer may also owe the Design and Building Practitioners Act duty if it had substantive control over the construction work.

Can a builder reduce its liability by blaming subcontractors?

For claims under the Design and Building Practitioners Act duty, the High Court held in Pafburn that a builder cannot use proportionate liability to shift responsibility to those whose work fell within its non-delegable duty. The builder may still bring cross-claims against them.

What is a building work rectification order?

An order that can be issued under the Residential Apartment Buildings Act requiring a developer to rectify serious defects in a residential apartment building. Failure to comply can have significant consequences, so a proposed order should be responded to promptly and carefully.