In this practice area
Claims by and against architects, engineers, designers, certifiers, project managers and other construction consultants, including statutory duty, contract and negligence claims and the insurance that responds.
When the design or the advice is the problem
Many building defects begin before construction does. An inadequate structural design, a façade specification that does not meet fire safety requirements, a waterproofing detail that cannot work as drawn, or a project manager's failure to coordinate trades can all produce loss that the builder alone is not responsible for. Construction professionals are increasingly joined to defect litigation, and increasingly pursued directly.
We act for owners corporations, developers, builders and principals bringing claims against construction professionals, and for professionals responding to them. The issues include the scope of the engagement, the applicable standard of care, causation, the statutory duty under the Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020 (NSW) and the professional indemnity insurance that will usually fund any recovery.
Contract, negligence and the statutory duty
A professional's obligations to its client are defined first by the engagement: the scope of services, the deliverables, any fitness for purpose obligation and any limitation of liability. Claims by the client are commonly brought in contract and negligence together. Claims by others, such as subsequent owners or an owners corporation, historically faced the difficulty that the common law rarely imposes a duty to avoid pure economic loss, as the High Court's decision in Brookfield Multiplex Ltd v Owners Corporation Strata Plan 61288 [2014] HCA 36 illustrates.
Part 4 of the Design and Building Practitioners Act changed that position. Construction work, for the purpose of the statutory duty, includes the preparation of regulated designs and other designs for building work, and supervising, coordinating or project managing that work. A designer or project manager may therefore owe owners and subsequent owners a duty to exercise reasonable care to avoid economic loss caused by defects, whether or not there is a contract with them. The duty cannot be contracted out of and cannot be delegated.
The position of certifiers requires particular care. A registered certifier exercises a public function and is regulated under the Building and Development Certifiers Act 2018 (NSW). Whether a certifier carries out construction work for the purpose of the statutory duty depends on its actual functions, and the question should not be answered by job title alone.
The standard of care and peer professional opinion
A professional is not liable simply because the outcome was poor. Under section 5O of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW), a professional is not negligent if it acted in a manner that, at the time, was widely accepted in Australia by peer professional opinion as competent professional practice, unless that opinion is irrational. The existence of differing peer opinions does not prevent reliance on one of them.
Expert evidence from a professional in the same discipline is therefore essential on both sides. The expert must address what a competent practitioner would have done at the time, with the information then available, rather than with hindsight. Causation must also be proved: that a different design or different advice would have avoided the loss.
Registration, design declarations and regulated buildings
For class 2 buildings, the Design and Building Practitioners Act has required since 1 July 2021 that regulated designs be prepared by registered design practitioners, who must provide design compliance declarations, and that building practitioners provide building compliance declarations. The regime was extended to new class 3 and class 9c buildings from 3 July 2023, and its extension to remedial work on existing class 3 and 9c buildings has been deferred until 1 July 2028. Professional engineering work in the prescribed areas, being civil, electrical, fire safety, geotechnical, mechanical and structural engineering, must be carried out by a registered engineer or under the required supervision.
Those declarations and registration requirements are regulatory, but they also generate evidence. A declaration that a design complies with the Building Code, when it does not, can be central to a claim against the practitioner who made it. Architects are separately regulated under the Architects Act 2003 (NSW). Registration and disciplinary processes do not replace civil liability, but they can run alongside it.
Proportionate liability, limitation and insurance
Claims for economic loss arising from a failure to take reasonable care are generally apportionable under Part 4 of the Civil Liability Act, which allows a professional to limit its liability to its share of responsibility. The High Court's decision in Pafburn Pty Ltd v The Owners – Strata Plan No 84674 [2024] HCA 49 affects that position where a defendant owes the non-delegable statutory duty, and the interaction must be analysed for each defendant and each claim.
Limitation periods run under the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW), generally six years from accrual, subject to the ten year long stop for building actions in section 6.20 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW).
Professional indemnity insurance is ordinarily written on a claims-made basis, so the policy year in which a claim or circumstance is notified determines which policy responds. Section 40(3) of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) can preserve cover where facts that might give rise to a claim are notified in writing during the policy period. Policy limits, retroactive dates, exclusions and run-off cover all affect whether a claim is worth pursuing, and a professional facing a claim should notify early. We work with our Insurance Coverage & Litigation practice where the insurer's response is in issue.
Legal framework

