Separated façade cladding panel and cracked render on a Sydney high-rise

Building & Construction Litigation

Building Defects & Construction Defect Litigation

In this practice area

Defect claims in commercial, residential and mixed-use buildings under contract, statute and negligence, from investigation and expert evidence to rectification cost, damages and trial.

01

A defect claim is proved, not presumed

The existence of a defect is usually the least contested part of a defects case. The real disputes concern why the defect exists, who is responsible for it, whether it breaches an enforceable obligation, and what it should cost to fix. A building can contain hundreds of alleged defects, each with a different cause and a different responsible party, and a claim that treats them as one problem is rarely persuasive.

We act for owners, principals, developers and builders in defect claims across commercial, industrial, residential and mixed-use buildings. Where strata common property is involved, the owners corporation's position raises distinct statutory issues, which we address separately. This page concerns the broader framework for proving and defending defect claims, wherever the building sits.

03

Investigation and expert evidence

Defects cases are won and lost on expert evidence. A building consultant's report prepared for a maintenance budget is not the same as evidence prepared for proceedings. For litigation, the expert must identify each defect, the standard it is said to breach, the cause, the responsible trade or design, and the scope and cost of reasonable rectification, and must comply with the expert witness code of conduct in Schedule 7 to the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW).

Multiple disciplines are often needed: a building consultant, a structural or façade engineer, a waterproofing or fire safety consultant and a quantity surveyor. Their reports must be consistent with one another and with the pleaded case. Joint expert conferences and joint reports are common in the Supreme Court, and the issues narrowed in those conferences frequently decide the result. Preparing experts for that process is as important as obtaining the first report.

Large defects cases may also be referred to a referee under Part 20 Division 3 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. The referee's report is not binding of its own force; the court decides whether to adopt, vary or reject it. A party that does not engage fully with the reference rarely recovers its position at the adoption stage.

04

Remedies: rectification cost, damages and the preferred outcome

The ordinary measure of damages for defective building work is the cost of rectification necessary to produce conformity with the contract, provided that course is reasonable. That principle, stated in Bellgrove v Eldridge (1954) 90 CLR 613 and affirmed in Tabcorp Holdings Ltd v Bowen Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 8, means that the reasonableness of the proposed scope is often the central battleground. Diminution in value, consequential loss, investigation costs, temporary works and loss of rent may also be recoverable on the facts.

For residential building work, section 48MA of the Home Building Act directs a court or tribunal to have regard to rectification by the responsible party as the preferred outcome. Courts can also make work orders. Where the relationship has broken down or the builder lacks the capacity to perform the work, the case for a money order should be developed in the evidence rather than simply asserted.

05

Limitation, proportionate liability and the defendants worth pursuing

Contract and negligence claims are generally subject to a six year limitation period from accrual under section 14 of the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW). Home Building Act warranty claims have their own six and two year periods from completion. Overlaying all of them is the ten year long stop for actions arising from defective building work in section 6.20 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW), running from the completion of the work as defined, usually by reference to the occupation certificate.

Defendants commonly rely on proportionate liability under Part 4 of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) to limit their liability to their share of the loss. Following Pafburn Pty Ltd v The Owners – Strata Plan No 84674 [2024] HCA 49, a defendant that owes the non-delegable duty under the Design and Building Practitioners Act cannot use that defence to shift responsibility to those whose work fell within its own duty. The interaction between those regimes affects which parties should be joined and in what capacity.

Finally, recovery depends on solvency and insurance. A builder may be in liquidation, a subcontractor may be uninsured and a consultant's professional indemnity policy may have a limit that is shared with other claims. Identifying where the money is should inform the claim from the beginning, not after judgment.

06

How we run defect proceedings

We act for claimants and respondents in defect litigation in NCAT and the Supreme Court of NSW. We prepare the chronology and the documents, scope and instruct the experts, plead the case precisely, and manage the expert process through to hearing. For respondents, we test causation, scope and cost, raise statutory defences and pursue cross-claims against the trades and consultants responsible. Each matter has direct partner involvement.

Frequently asked questions

Building Defects & Construction Defect Litigation

Does the defects liability period limit how long I have to claim?

Usually not. A defects liability period is ordinarily a contractual mechanism for the contractor to return and rectify defects. Claims for breach of contract are generally subject to the Limitation Act, and statutory claims have their own periods, all subject to the ten year long stop for building actions.

Can I claim against a subcontractor or designer I did not contract with?

Potentially. Part 4 of the Design and Building Practitioners Act imposes a duty of reasonable care on persons who carry out construction work, including design work and supervision, owed to owners and subsequent owners. Whether a particular party owes the duty depends on what it actually did.

How are damages for defective work usually measured?

Generally by the reasonable cost of rectification needed to bring the work into conformity with the contract. Whether the proposed scope is necessary and reasonable is often the main dispute, so the rectification evidence needs careful preparation.

Can a defendant reduce its liability by blaming others?

Proportionate liability may apply to some claims for economic loss. However, the High Court held in Pafburn that a defendant owing the non-delegable statutory duty under the Design and Building Practitioners Act cannot shift responsibility in that way to those whose work fell within its duty.

Should we repair the defects before proceedings?

Sometimes repairs cannot wait, particularly for safety or water ingress. Before work begins, the defect, its cause and the scope of the repair should be properly recorded and, where practicable, the other side given the opportunity to inspect. Undocumented repairs can make a claim difficult to prove.