Unfinished elevated rail viaduct with an idle launching gantry at dusk

Building & Construction Litigation

Construction Delays & Project Disputes

In this practice area

Extension of time and delay cost claims, liquidated damages, disruption and acceleration, practical completion and superintendent disputes on building and infrastructure projects.

01

Delay is a question of cause, not only of time

Every late project has a story about why it was late. A delay dispute asks whether that story can be proved against the programme, the contract and the records. Late design information, authority approvals, utility connections, latent conditions, variations, weather, labour shortages and the performance of other contractors can each delay the critical path, and the contract allocates the risk of each event differently.

We act for principals, developers, head contractors, subcontractors and authorities in delay disputes on building and infrastructure projects. The financial stakes are often greater than the cost of the work itself: liquidated damages, prolongation costs, lost revenue from late occupation and financing costs can all depend on whether a single extension of time was granted.

03

The prevention principle and concurrent delay

The prevention principle holds that a principal cannot insist on a completion date, or recover liquidated damages, where its own conduct prevented the contractor from completing on time, unless the contract provides a mechanism to extend time for that conduct. An effective extension of time clause usually answers the problem; where it does not, time may be at large and the contractor obliged to complete within a reasonable time.

Concurrent delay, where a contractor caused delay and a principal caused delay at the same time, has no single settled answer in Australian law. Many contracts now address it directly, either by allowing time but not costs or by excluding an extension altogether. The outcome usually depends on the contract's wording and on detailed programme evidence about which events actually affected completion.

04

Delay costs, disruption and acceleration

An extension of time and an entitlement to delay costs are different things. Contracts commonly allow delay costs only for specified causes, at specified rates or subject to caps. Prolongation claims for extended site overheads must be supported by actual cost records, and disruption claims, alleging that work became less productive rather than later, require evidence that connects cause and effect.

Courts are cautious about global or total cost claims that do not link particular events to particular losses. A contractor who accelerated to avoid liquidated damages after an extension was wrongly refused may have a claim for the cost of acceleration, but it must prove both the entitlement it was denied and the cost it incurred as a result.

05

Programme evidence and the project record

Delay disputes are decided on programming evidence. A forensic delay analyst will typically examine the baseline and updated programmes, the as-built record and contemporaneous documents to determine the critical path and the effect of each delaying event. The method chosen, whether an as-planned versus as-built comparison, a windows analysis or another approach, can significantly influence the result, and the opposing expert will test it.

That analysis is only as reliable as the project record. Site diaries, minutes, requests for information, notices, photographs and correspondence made at the time are far more persuasive than reconstruction after the event. Preserving and organising that record early is one of the most valuable steps a party can take.

06

Practical completion, superintendents and infrastructure projects

Practical completion triggers the release of security, the end of liquidated damages and often the start of the defects liability period, so disputes about whether it has been achieved are common. The definition in the contract governs, and it frequently depends on certificates, documentation and authority approvals as well as physical works.

A superintendent who assesses claims and certifies completion must act honestly and impartially in performing those functions, as recognised in Perini Corporation v Commonwealth (1969) 12 BLR 82. On infrastructure and large building projects, delay can arise from interfaces with authorities, utilities and other contractors who are not parties to the head contract, and the contractual chain must be traced to identify who bears that risk and who can be pursued.

Frequently asked questions

Construction Delays & Project Disputes

If we missed the notice deadline, have we lost our extension of time?

Possibly. Courts generally enforce contractual time bars. However, the contract may contain a power for the superintendent or principal to extend time regardless, and the principal's conduct may be relevant. The wording of the contract and the correspondence should be reviewed promptly.

Can a principal claim liquidated damages if it caused part of the delay?

Not for delay it caused, unless the contract allows time to be extended for that delay and the extension is properly assessed. Where there is no effective mechanism, the prevention principle may prevent liquidated damages being recovered.

Does an extension of time mean we are entitled to delay costs?

Not necessarily. Many contracts grant time without costs for some events, limit the costs recoverable or require separate notice of a cost claim. Entitlement to time and entitlement to money must be analysed separately.

What evidence do we need for a delay claim?

Usually the baseline and updated programmes, the as-built record, notices and correspondence, site records and cost records, analysed by a forensic programming expert. Contemporaneous records are far more persuasive than later reconstruction.