Sydney commercial tower under construction with a partly installed glass façade

Building & Construction Litigation

Construction Contract & Commercial Disputes

In this practice area

Variations, latent conditions, final accounts, termination, liquidated damages, bank guarantees and dispute resolution clauses in head contracts, subcontracts and consultancy agreements.

01

The contract allocates the risk; the dispute tests it

Most construction disputes are, at their core, disputes about the contract: what was included in the price, who carried the risk of a particular event, whether a notice was given in time and what each party may do when the relationship breaks down. Standard forms such as AS 4000 and AS 4902 are frequently amended so heavily that the special conditions matter more than the general conditions. The answer to a construction dispute is rarely found in the clause headings.

We act for principals, developers, head contractors, subcontractors and consultants in disputes about variations, latent conditions, final accounts, defects, termination, security and liquidated damages. Our focus is contested matters with commercial significance, where the contract, the correspondence and the conduct of the project all have to be brought together.

03

Termination, show cause and repudiation

Termination is the most consequential step in a construction project and one of the most frequently mishandled. Contractual termination usually requires a show cause or default notice in a prescribed form, a specified period to respond and a proper assessment of the response. A notice that misdescribes the default or a termination that does not follow the contractual process can itself amount to repudiation, reversing the positions of the parties.

Where a contract is terminated for repudiation, the contractor's remedies are not unlimited. In Mann v Paterson Constructions Pty Ltd [2019] HCA 32, the High Court held that accrued contractual rights to payment remain governed by the contract, and that any restitutionary claim for incomplete work is generally limited by the contract price. Takeover of the works, the treatment of plant and materials on site, assignment of subcontracts and the final reconciliation of costs all need to be planned before the notice is served.

04

Liquidated damages, security and bank guarantees

Liquidated damages clauses are generally enforceable. Following Paciocco v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2016] HCA 28, a stipulated sum is not penal merely because it is not an exact pre-estimate of loss; the question is whether it is extravagant or out of all proportion to the innocent party's legitimate interests. Disputes more often concern whether the contractor was entitled to an extension of time, whether the principal's conduct prevented completion and whether the clause operates on its terms.

Calls on bank guarantees and other security are a frequent flashpoint. Courts treat unconditional security as a risk allocation device, and a genuine dispute about the underlying liability is not itself a reason to stop a call. In Clough Engineering Ltd v Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Ltd [2008] FCAFC 136, the Full Federal Court identified fraud, statutory unconscionability and a contractual restriction on the right to call as the relevant grounds. Whether the contract limits the right to call, for example by requiring an entitlement to be established first, depends on careful construction, and an urgent injunction application must be ready within hours, not days.

05

Unfair terms, misleading conduct and statutory overlays

Since 9 November 2023, unfair contract terms in standard form small business contracts have been prohibited under the Australian Consumer Law, with civil penalties available. Subcontracts issued on a head contractor's standard terms may be within that regime, depending on the parties and the circumstances. Misleading or deceptive conduct claims under section 18 of the Australian Consumer Law may also arise from representations made during tender or negotiation.

Payment disputes run in parallel under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW), which cannot be contracted out of. A contractual dispute and a statutory adjudication about the same money can proceed at the same time, and the positions taken in one will be scrutinised in the other.

06

Dispute resolution clauses and forum

Construction contracts commonly require notice of dispute, executive negotiation and expert determination or arbitration before litigation. A court will ordinarily refer a dispute within a valid arbitration agreement to arbitration under section 8 of the Commercial Arbitration Act 2010 (NSW), and arbitral awards can be challenged only on limited grounds. Expert determination is not arbitration; its binding effect depends on the contract and on whether the expert performed the task the parties gave them.

Where proceedings are brought in court, the Technology and Construction List of the Supreme Court of NSW, governed by Practice Note SC Eq 3, offers active case management for construction disputes. Choosing whether to insist on, or resist, a contractual dispute process is itself a significant decision, and the time and cost implications should be considered before a notice of dispute is served.

Frequently asked questions

Construction Contract & Commercial Disputes

Can a contractor be paid for a variation that was not directed in writing?

Sometimes. The contract may require written directions and notices, and failure to comply can defeat a claim. However, the principal's conduct, any waiver or estoppel, and the statutory payment regime may all be relevant. The answer depends on the contract and the evidence.

Can we stop a principal from calling on our bank guarantee?

Only on limited grounds, such as fraud, unconscionable conduct or a contractual restriction on the right to call. A dispute about whether the money is owed is generally not enough. If the contract restricts the call, an urgent injunction application may be possible.

Are liquidated damages a penalty?

Usually not. A liquidated damages clause will be penal only if the amount is extravagant or out of all proportion to the legitimate interests it protects. Disputes more commonly concern extensions of time and whether the principal prevented completion.

What should happen before a construction contract is terminated?

The contractual default and termination process should be followed precisely, the response assessed and the consequences planned, including takeover of the works, security and subcontracts. An invalid termination can amount to repudiation by the party that served it.

Do we have to go to expert determination or arbitration first?

If the contract contains a valid dispute resolution clause, a court will usually require the parties to follow it, and a valid arbitration agreement will ordinarily lead to a referral to arbitration. Urgent relief may still be available from a court.