Aerial view of a Sydney construction site with tower cranes at dawn

Building & Construction Litigation

Security of Payment & Adjudication Disputes

In this practice area

Payment claims, payment schedules, adjudication applications and responses, enforcement and Supreme Court challenges under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW).

01

A fast process with lasting consequences

The Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) gives a person who carries out construction work, or supplies related goods and services, under a construction contract an entitlement to progress payments and a rapid means of enforcing it. The process is deliberately quick and interim. An adjudicator's determination does not finally decide the parties' rights, but it usually decides who holds the money while those rights are litigated, and for a contractor or subcontractor that can decide whether the business survives the dispute.

The Act cannot be contracted out of, and pay when paid provisions are of no effect. For contracts entered into on or after 21 October 2019, the regime no longer depends on reference dates in the way it once did, and since 1 March 2021 owner-occupier residential contracts have generally been within the Act. Older contracts require transitional analysis.

03

Due dates and the timetable for adjudication

A progress payment from a principal to a head contractor is due no later than 15 business days after the payment claim is made, and from a head contractor to a subcontractor no later than 20 business days, unless the contract provides for an earlier date. Different rules apply to exempt residential construction contracts.

Where the scheduled amount is less than the claimed amount, the claimant may apply for adjudication within 10 business days after receiving the schedule. Where the scheduled amount is not paid, it may apply within 20 business days after the due date. Where no schedule was served, the claimant must first give notice of its intention to apply and allow the respondent a further opportunity to provide a schedule, before applying within the prescribed period.

The respondent's adjudication response is due within five business days after receiving the application or two business days after receiving notice of the adjudicator's acceptance, whichever is later. The adjudicator then has a short period to determine the application, ordinarily 10 business days, unless the parties agree to more time. The adjudicator may consider only the Act, the contract, the claim and schedule with their properly made submissions, and any inspection. Time is counted under the version of the Act that applies, so the counting rules should be confirmed for each claim.

04

Preparing the application or response

Adjudication rewards preparation. The claimant's submissions and evidence must establish the value of the work, the contractual basis for each item and the answer to every reason given in the schedule. A respondent must have its case largely prepared when the schedule is served, because the schedule confines the reasons it can rely on and the response window is short. Expert valuation, programme analysis and a clear chronology often need to be in place within days.

Large payment claims, final claims after termination and claims that include delay costs, variations and disputed set offs can be complex. An adjudicator is required to value the work under the contract, so the clauses governing variations, time, liquidated damages and security need to be addressed directly rather than left for the adjudicator to find.

05

Enforcement, challenges and the final position

If an adjudicated amount is not paid, the claimant can obtain an adjudication certificate and file it as a judgment debt in a court of competent jurisdiction. It may also suspend work after giving the required notice. A respondent that applies to set aside the resulting judgment cannot bring a cross-claim, raise a contractual defence or challenge the determination in those proceedings, and must pay the unpaid adjudicated amount into court as security.

A determination can be challenged in the Supreme Court of NSW for jurisdictional error, including a denial of procedural fairness or a failure to perform the statutory task. In Probuild Constructions (Aust) Pty Ltd v Shade Systems Pty Ltd [2018] HCA 4, the High Court held that the Act excludes review for non-jurisdictional error of law. Since the 2019 amendments, the court may set aside only the affected part of a determination and confirm the remainder. A challenge must therefore identify a true jurisdictional error, not simply a wrong answer.

Payments under the Act are interim. Under section 32, the parties' rights under the contract are preserved, and in final proceedings a court must take account of amounts paid and may order restitution. A party that loses an adjudication is not necessarily out of pocket permanently, but it will usually need final proceedings or an agreed resolution to recover the money.

06

Retention money, liquidation and other protections

Head contractors on qualifying projects with a contract value of at least $20 million must hold subcontractors' retention money in a trust account under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Regulation 2020, and that money is not available to meet the head contractor's own debts. The Act also permits an unpaid claimant to request that a principal withhold money owed to the defaulting party, and the Contractors Debts Act 1997 (NSW) provides a separate mechanism for reaching money payable by a principal to a defaulting contractor.

A corporation in liquidation cannot serve a payment claim or take action to enforce one under the Act, and an unresolved adjudication application is taken to be withdrawn on liquidation. Where insolvency is a risk, the timing of claims and enforcement becomes critical.

Frequently asked questions

Security of Payment & Adjudication Disputes

What happens if we do not serve a payment schedule in time?

The claimant can recover the full claimed amount as a debt, and in those proceedings the respondent generally cannot rely on contractual defences or cross-claims. The claimant may also proceed to adjudication after giving the required notice.

Can we raise new reasons in the adjudication response?

No. A respondent cannot include in its adjudication response reasons for withholding payment that were not included in its payment schedule. The schedule should therefore contain every genuine reason, with enough detail to be understood.

Can an adjudicator's determination be overturned?

Only for jurisdictional error, such as a failure to perform the statutory task or a denial of procedural fairness. The Supreme Court will not review a determination simply because the adjudicator made an error of law within jurisdiction. The parties' final rights can still be decided in later proceedings.

Does the Act apply to homeowners?

Owner-occupier residential construction contracts entered into on or after 1 March 2021 are generally within the Act, with specific rules about due dates for exempt residential contracts. Earlier contracts may be treated differently.

Can a company in liquidation use the Act?

No. A corporation in liquidation cannot serve a payment claim or take action under the Act to enforce one, and a pending adjudication application is taken to be withdrawn. The liquidator may still pursue contractual rights by other means.