The owners of a Rose Bay home engaged a company to renovate it. Neither the company nor its director held a licence under the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW), and the owners were not told. The work was left incomplete and defective. In September 2026, the District Court made orders totalling more than $876,000, most of it payable by the company and its director jointly.

The decision, Tan v Platinumhomeland Pty Ltd [2026] NSWDC 343, needs to be read with care. The builder and director filed a defence, then stopped taking part. The defence was struck out, judgment was entered and the Court assessed damages without a contested trial on liability. Even so, the Court's reasons are a useful illustration. It found that the director personally owed the statutory duty of care as a person who carried out construction work, and that the cost of rectification was the right measure of the owners' loss.

When building work goes wrong, owners in NSW often have more options than they realise. Those options depend on acting early, keeping evidence and choosing the right path. This article is for homeowners and owners corporations who have found, or suspect, defects in residential building work.

01 The short version

  • You usually have more than one claim. The main ones are the statutory warranties under the Home Building Act and the statutory duty of care under the Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020 (NSW). The duty can reach developers and individuals, not only the builder you contracted with.
  • Time limits are strict and differ between claims. Warranty claims generally run for two years from completion, or six years for a major defect. Other claims have their own limitation periods, and a 10-year long-stop applies to most claims for defective building work.
  • NCAT usually expects a complaint first. Most home building applications must first go through the complaint and dispute resolution process, but there are important exceptions, including claims against unlicensed contractors and claims about to run out of time.
  • Evidence decides cases. An independent expert report is usually the most important document in a defects claim.

02 Statutory warranties under the Home Building Act

The Home Building Act implies statutory warranties into every contract to do residential building work, whether or not the contract mentions them. In summary, the person doing the work warrants that:

  • the work will be done with due care and skill and in accordance with the plans and specifications in the contract;
  • the materials supplied will be good and suitable for their purpose and, unless the contract says otherwise, new;
  • the work will be done in accordance with, and will comply with, the law, which includes the Building Code of Australia;
  • the work will be done with due diligence and within the time stated in the contract or, if none is stated, within a reasonable time;
  • where the work is the construction, alteration, repair or renovation of a dwelling, the dwelling will be reasonably fit for occupation; and
  • where the contract states a particular purpose or result, the work and materials will be reasonably fit for that purpose or of a nature that can reasonably be expected to achieve that result.

The warranties are not limited to the original owner. Later owners of the property can generally rely on them, and a developer who did not do the work itself can be bound by them as if it were the builder. Any term of a contract that tries to exclude or restrict the warranties is void, so a short defects liability period in the contract does not reduce them.

Whether a defect is a major defect matters because it decides how long you have to bring proceedings. Broadly, a major defect is a defect in a major element of a building, such as a load-bearing component essential to its stability, a fire safety system or waterproofing, caused by defective design, faulty workmanship, defective materials or non-compliance with the Building Code of Australia. It must also cause, or be likely to cause, the inability to inhabit or use the building or part of it for its intended purpose, the destruction of the building or part of it, or a threat of collapse.

03 The statutory duty of care

Since 10 June 2020, a person who carries out construction work has owed a statutory duty to exercise reasonable care to avoid economic loss caused by defects in or related to a building. Construction work includes building work, preparing designs, manufacturing or supplying building products, and supervising, coordinating, project managing or otherwise having substantive control over that work. The duty is owed to the owner and to later owners. It operates alongside the warranties and has three practical advantages.

  • It reaches people you never contracted with. Depending on what they actually did, that may include a developer, a subcontractor, a designer, or a director or project manager who carried out or controlled the work.
  • It cannot be contracted out of. The duty cannot be excluded, limited or transferred by agreement.
  • Defendants cannot shift the loss to those they engaged. In Pafburn Pty Limited v The Owners - Strata Plan No 84674 [2024] HCA 49, the High Court held that a developer and builder sued under the duty could not reduce their liability by apportioning it to the subcontractors and consultants to whom they had delegated or entrusted the work. Our article on the High Court's decision in Pafburn explains what was decided and what was left open.

Courts look closely at each person's actual role. In The Owners - Strata Plan No 92183 v Samdora Pty Ltd [2026] NSWSC 406, the director of the builder, who was also its nominated supervisor, was found liable. The claim against a director of the developer was dismissed because the evidence did not show that he carried out construction work or had substantive control over it. A title alone is not enough, and neither is a list of defects. The owner still needs to show that reasonable care was not taken and that the failure caused the loss.

The duty is being moved into the new Building (Approvals and Practitioners) Act 2026 (NSW), which received assent on 14 August 2026. Most of that Act commences on a date to be proclaimed, and it carries the duty forward with some changes. Until the relevant provisions commence, the duty in the Design and Building Practitioners Act continues to apply. Which version governs a particular claim should be checked when advice is sought.

04 Complaints and orders from Building Commission NSW

For a home building dispute, you can lodge a complaint through NSW Fair Trading. The home building dispute resolution service is now run by Building Commission NSW. An inspector may assess the complaint, attend the site and try to help the parties reach agreement. If the inspector considers the builder is responsible for defective or incomplete work, a rectification order may be issued directing the builder to fix or complete the work by a due date. Failing to comply with that order is a breach of the Home Building Act.

For residential apartment buildings and certain other building classes, Building Commission NSW has separate powers to issue a building work rectification order, usually to the developer, requiring serious defects to be fixed. Failing to comply is a criminal offence. In 2025, the Commission began prosecuting developers and their directors in the Land and Environment Court for not complying with these orders. What happens after such an order is made is covered in our article on building work rectification orders.

A regulator's order can get work fixed without you running a case. It does not, however, stop your time limits running. It should not replace legal action where a deadline is approaching.

05 Time limits: the biggest trap

Many otherwise strong claims are lost because they were started too late. For warranty claims, the clock usually starts when the work is completed, not when you notice the problem. The main deadlines are:

  • Statutory warranty, major defect: six years from completion of the work.
  • Statutory warranty, any other defect: two years from completion of the work.
  • Breach that becomes apparent in the last six months of either warranty period: proceedings may be brought within a further six months after the period ends.
  • Statutory duty of care and negligence: generally six years from when the cause of action accrues. Courts have treated loss from defective construction as arising when the defects become manifest or are discovered, although that question can be contested.
  • The long-stop: section 6.20 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) generally prevents a civil action for loss or damage arising from defective building work being brought more than 10 years after completion. It is an outer limit. It does not extend a shorter limitation period that has already expired.

Two practical points follow.

  • A complaint does not stop the clock. If a deadline is within three months, NCAT will accept an application without first requiring the complaint process to be completed.
  • Completion can be arguable. The Act has its own rules for working out the date of completion. For a new building in a strata scheme, it is generally the date of the occupation certificate for the whole building. Get advice early rather than assuming you have time.

06 Where to bring your claim

The complaint process first, in most cases

NCAT generally requires evidence that a home building dispute has been through the complaint process before it will accept an application. The exceptions include claims involving unlicensed contractors, claims against companies that have been deregistered, claims against companies or individuals in administration, liquidation or bankruptcy, appeals against an insurer's decision, and claims where the time for lodging is due to expire within three months. In a case like the Rose Bay matter, the owners would not need to wait for the complaint process.

NCAT for most home building claims

The NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal hears home building claims up to $500,000. It is designed to be quicker and less formal than a court. Parties can seek leave to be legally represented, which is often granted in larger or more complex claims. The Tribunal's Appeal Panel has treated a claim for breach of the statutory duty of care as a building claim that the Tribunal can hear, including in Deaves v Sigma Group NSW Pty Limited [2023] NSWCATAP 94.

Court for larger or more complex claims

Claims above $500,000, claims about commercial work, and complex multi-party strata disputes usually belong in the District Court or the Supreme Court. If a claim grows beyond the Tribunal's limit once expert evidence comes in, it may be possible to transfer it to a court. That is what happened in the Rose Bay matter.

07 If the builder has collapsed

Construction insolvencies remain high. ASIC's insolvency statistics record 3,472 construction companies entering external administration or having a controller appointed for the first time in the 2025 to 2026 financial year. If your builder has collapsed, you may still have options.

  • Home Building Compensation Fund cover. A licensed contractor must generally obtain this cover for residential building work over $20,000 before taking a deposit or starting work. A claim can be made if the builder has died, disappeared, become insolvent or had its licence suspended for failing to comply with a money order made by NCAT or a court. Finding defects is not enough on its own. Cover periods, limits and notification requirements apply, so tell icare in writing as soon as you become aware of a problem, even before a trigger event occurs.
  • Claims against other people. The statutory duty of care may reach a developer, a director who carried out or controlled the work, or others involved, even when the builder company has gone.
  • Proving in the liquidation. You can lodge a proof of debt with the liquidator, although returns to unsecured creditors are often low.

An unlicensed builder is very unlikely to have arranged compensation fund cover. If the builder was unlicensed or uninsured, act quickly. As the Rose Bay matter shows, a director who personally ran the work may still be liable.

08 Practical steps if you find defects

  1. Record everything. Take dated photos and videos, and keep a log of when each issue appeared and how it has changed.
  2. Gather your documents. Keep the contract, plans and specifications, variations, invoices, the insurance certificate, the occupation certificate and all correspondence with the builder.
  3. Get an independent expert report. Use a qualified building consultant with no connection to the builder. A useful report identifies each defect, the standard it fails to meet, its likely cause and the reasonable cost of fixing it.
  4. Notify the builder in writing. Describe each defect, attach the evidence, and give the builder a reasonable time to respond and to access the site, subject to any process in the contract.
  5. Notify icare if the builder has died, disappeared, become insolvent or stopped responding and the work was covered by a compensation fund certificate.
  6. Lodge a complaint and diarise your deadlines. If a time limit is close, get legal advice about starting proceedings at the same time.
  7. Get advice on who to claim against. The builder may not be the only, or the best, defendant.

09 Common mistakes to avoid

  • Fixing it yourself first. If another builder is engaged before the defects are properly documented, it may be hard to prove what was wrong. Except in a genuine emergency, document the defects and get advice before rectification starts.
  • Relying on informal promises. Repeated assurances that the builder will come back next week do not stop the clock.
  • Claiming against the wrong party. A builder company with no assets may be a poor target when a developer, a director or the compensation fund may be available.
  • Thin evidence. A list of problems is not enough. Tribunals and courts expect expert evidence linking each defect to a breach and to a cost.
  • Assuming the contract limits your rights. A short defects liability period in the contract does not reduce your statutory warranty rights.
  • Arguing about the wrong number. The measure of loss is often contested. Our article on rectification costs and diminution in value explains when the cost of repair is recoverable.

10 How GopherWood Lawyers can help

GopherWood Lawyers acts for homeowners and owners corporations in building defect disputes. We can help you identify the claims available to you and the right parties to bring them against, work out your deadlines, brief the right expert, and run your claim through the complaint process, NCAT or the courts. If you have found defects, or think the builder may be in financial trouble, contact us early. Your time limits may already be running.

Learn more about our building defects and construction defect litigation work, or contact GopherWood Lawyers to discuss your matter.

This article provides general information about the law in New South Wales as at 12 November 2026. It is not legal advice. Time limits and rights depend on the type of work, the contract and when the work was completed. You should obtain advice about your specific circumstances.

11 Sources and further reading

  1. Home Building Act 1989 (NSW): especially ss 3B, 18B to 18G, 48A and 48K.
  2. Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020 (NSW): especially ss 36 to 41.
  3. Building (Approvals and Practitioners) Act 2026 (NSW), and the Parliament of NSW bill page.
  4. Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW): s 6.20.
  5. Limitation Act 1969 (NSW): s 14.
  6. Tan v Platinumhomeland Pty Ltd [2026] NSWDC 343, and Insurance Business report on the decision.
  7. The Owners - Strata Plan No 92183 v Samdora Pty Ltd [2026] NSWSC 406.
  8. Pafburn Pty Limited v The Owners - Strata Plan No 84674 [2024] HCA 49.
  9. Deaves v Sigma Group NSW Pty Limited [2023] NSWCATAP 94.
  10. Cyril Smith & Associates Pty Ltd v The Owners - Strata Plan No 64970 [2011] NSWCA 181.
  11. NCAT: Home building, including the list of matters exempt from the complaint requirement.
  12. Building Commission NSW: Home building dispute resolution.
  13. Building Commission NSW: About orders from Building Commission NSW.
  14. icare: HBCF, am I ready to make a claim?
  15. ASIC: Insolvency statistics, Series 1.