A building work rectification order is one of the most significant steps Building Commission NSW can take against a developer. It can arrive during construction, shortly before an occupation certificate is sought, or years after residents have moved in.
The order requires specified work to be done to fix a serious defect, or to stop one arising. It is not a request. Failing to comply is a criminal offence, the order is published on a public register while it remains in force, and the time to appeal is short.
The first weeks after an order is received matter most. This article explains the legal basis for these orders, who receives them, how the remediation process usually runs, how an order can be challenged and how the cost can be pursued against those responsible.
01 What is a building work rectification order?
Building work rectification orders are made under section 33 of the Residential Apartment Buildings (Compliance and Enforcement Powers) Act 2020 (NSW) (RAB Act). The power belongs to the Secretary and is exercised in practice by Building Commission NSW.
An order may be given to a developer if the Secretary has a reasonable belief that building work was or is being carried out in a way that could result in a serious defect in the building, or that the building has a serious defect. The order may require the developer to ensure that specified building work is carried out or not carried out, or to take other specified action, to eliminate, minimise or remediate the defect.
Two features are easy to overlook. First, an order can be made before any damage has occurred, because the test includes work that could result in a serious defect. Second, it can be made while construction is still under way or after completion. The RAB Act applies to class 2 apartment buildings, and Building Commission NSW states that its powers now also extend to class 3 and class 9c buildings, such as boarding houses and residential aged care. The powers can be used for up to 10 years after a building is completed.
02 What counts as a serious defect?
The definition of "serious defect" in the RAB Act centres on building elements, which include the fire safety systems, waterproofing, structure and building enclosure, and certain building services.
In broad terms, a serious defect includes a defect in a building element caused by a failure to comply with the performance requirements of the Building Code of Australia, the relevant Australian Standards or the approved plans. It also includes a defect that causes, or is likely to cause, the building or part of it to be unusable for its intended purpose, its destruction or a threat of its collapse, and the use of a building product in breach of the Building Products (Safety) Act 2017 (NSW).
Whether a particular item meets that definition is often the first legal question to test when an order arrives.
03 Who receives the order?
Orders are given to the "developer", a term the RAB Act defines much more widely than its everyday meaning. It includes the person who contracted or arranged for, facilitated or otherwise caused the building work to be carried out, directly or indirectly; the owner of the land when the work was done, where the work is the erection of a building; the principal contractor; and the developer of the strata scheme.
That means a builder can be a "developer" for these purposes, and more than one party can fall within the definition. It also means the party receiving the order may not be the one that did the defective work. A developer can be ordered to fix waterproofing or structural work carried out by its head contractor or a subcontractor. Its rights against those parties are separate, and they do not relieve it of the obligation to comply.
A copy of the order is usually provided to the owners corporation, which may make submissions about the defects. The order itself, however, is a matter between the regulator and the developer.
04 What happens after an order is issued
Building Commission NSW describes a general process, which can vary from building to building:
Throughout that process the developer should keep a complete record: investigations, designs, the remediation plan, communications with the regulator and the owners corporation, and evidence of the work done. That record supports compliance and any later claim to recover the cost.
05 Challenging the order in the Land and Environment Court
Under section 49 of the RAB Act, a developer who is given an order may appeal to the Land and Environment Court. The appeal must be made within 30 days after the order is given, unless the Court grants leave to appeal later. Leave should not be assumed.
Possible grounds include that an item is not a serious defect, that the required work goes further than needed, or that the statutory preconditions for the order were not met. On an appeal, the Court may revoke or modify the order, substitute any other order the Secretary could have given, find that the order has been sufficiently complied with, or make other orders about compliance.
Lodging an appeal does not stop the order having effect unless the Court orders otherwise. A developer that wants relief from compliance while the appeal is pending must ask for it.
Appeals are often resolved without a full hearing. In Phoenix Palm Development Pty Ltd v The Secretary of the Department of Customer Service [2024] NSWLEC 1812, for example, the parties reached agreement at a conciliation conference and the Court substituted an agreed order for the one originally issued.
06 If the order is not complied with
An order continues to have effect after any compliance date passes, unless it is revoked. Building Commission NSW states that the maximum penalty for failing to comply is 3,000 penalty units for a company, plus 300 penalty units for each day the offence continues, and 1,000 penalty units for an individual, plus 100 penalty units for each day.
The regulator may also ask the Land and Environment Court to order compliance, issue a stop work order where work is unsafe, and prosecute. Any fine is paid to the government, not to the owners corporation. Where the developer also holds a contractor licence, Building Commission NSW may consider disciplinary action, which can include fines and, in some cases, disqualification of the company and its nominated supervisor.
Because orders appear on the public register while they are in force, non-compliance also carries commercial and reputational consequences for future projects, financing and sales.
07 Engaging with Building Commission NSW
Constructive engagement with the regulator is usually the most efficient route to compliance. Where there are genuine difficulties, such as access problems, the need for further investigation or a remediation method that differs from the one first contemplated, they should be raised early and supported with expert material.
The RAB Act allows the Secretary, by written notice, to impose, vary or revoke conditions of an order. Discussions with officers do not, by themselves, change the order or extend a deadline. Any agreed change should be confirmed in writing before the developer relies on it.
08 Recovering the cost from those responsible
A developer that has paid to fix defects caused by a builder, subcontractor or consultant may be able to recover that cost. Depending on the contracts and the facts, the avenues can include claims for breach of contract, contractual indemnities, negligence and claims under the statutory duty of care in the Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020 (NSW).
For example, a developer that incurs substantial costs to rectify structural defects caused by negligent engineering design may seek to recover those costs from the engineer. Success will depend on the terms of the engagement, the evidence of causation and loss, and the engineer's insurance position.
Two points need care. A dispute with contractors does not excuse non-compliance with the order. And the same defects may also give rise to claims by the owners corporation, where the High Court's decision on proportionate liability is relevant. We discuss that decision in our article on Pafburn and proportionate liability.
09 First steps after receiving an order
- Diarise the 30-day appeal deadline and every compliance date in the order.
- Obtain advice on whether each item meets the definition of a serious defect and whether the order is open to challenge.
- Engage independent engineers and consultants to investigate the defects and the proposed method of rectification.
- Decide quickly whether to appeal, and whether to seek relief from compliance while an appeal is pending.
- Open a structured line of communication with Building Commission NSW and the owners corporation.
- Notify insurers and review contracts with builders, subcontractors and consultants for notice requirements and recovery rights.
- Preserve construction records, including drawings, inspection reports, certificates, site photographs and correspondence.
10 How GopherWood Lawyers can help
A rectification order combines regulatory, technical and commercial pressure on short timeframes. The best outcomes usually come from making the key decisions on appeal, engagement and recovery early.
GopherWood Lawyers acts for developers, builders and construction professionals responding to Building Commission NSW investigations and orders. We advise on the scope and validity of orders, run appeals in the Land and Environment Court, manage engagement with the regulator and pursue recovery from the parties responsible for defective work. Learn more about our builder, developer and contractor litigation work, or contact GopherWood Lawyers to discuss your matter.
This article provides general information about the law in New South Wales as at 10 November 2026. It is not legal advice. Building laws in NSW are changing, and the obligations in each case depend on the order, the building and the facts.
11 Sources and further reading
- Residential Apartment Buildings (Compliance and Enforcement Powers) Act 2020 (NSW): especially ss 3, 4, 33 and 49.
- RAB Act s 33: Power to order rectification.
- RAB Act s 49: Appeals concerning orders.
- Building Commission NSW: About orders from Building Commission NSW.
- Building Commission NSW: Intervention on regulated building issues.
- Phoenix Palm Development Pty Ltd v The Secretary of the Department of Customer Service [2024] NSWLEC 1812.
- Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020 (NSW): s 37.

