Most building defect claims involve a long chain of people. A developer engages a head contractor, the head contractor engages subcontractors, and architects, engineers, certifiers and product suppliers each play a part. When defects appear, every party in that chain tends to point to someone else.

For claims under the statutory duty of care in the Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020 (NSW) (DBP Act), the High Court has narrowed how far developers and head contractors can do that. In Pafburn Pty Limited v The Owners - Strata Plan No 84674 [2024] HCA 49, a majority held that a developer and head contractor sued under section 37 of the DBP Act could not use proportionate liability to reduce their exposure by blaming the subcontractors and others to whom they had delegated or entrusted the work.

The practical result is that the risk of an insolvent or uninsured subcontractor now sits with the party at the top of the chain. This article explains the duty, what the Court decided, what it left open and what developers and builders should be doing about it.

01 The statutory duty of care

Section 37 of the DBP Act provides that a person who carries out construction work has a duty to exercise reasonable care to avoid economic loss caused by defects in or related to a building for which the work is done, and arising from that work. The duty is owed to each owner of the land and to each subsequent owner, whether or not the work was done under a contract with that owner.

"Construction work" is defined broadly. It includes building work, preparing designs, manufacturing or supplying building products, and supervising, coordinating, project managing or otherwise having substantive control over the carrying out of any of that work. A developer that controls a project can owe the duty even though it never lifted a tool.

Section 39 provides that a person who owes the duty is not entitled to delegate it. The duty also cannot be contracted out of. For owners corporations and subsequent purchasers, who often have no contract with the builder, the duty offers a direct claim that the general law of negligence did not reliably provide.

02 What happened in Pafburn

The case concerned a residential apartment building in North Sydney constructed between about 2008 and 2010. The owners corporation sued the developer, Madarina Pty Ltd, and the head contractor, Pafburn Pty Ltd, alleging breaches of the section 37 duty. Its claim was based solely on the DBP Act.

Both defendants pleaded a proportionate liability defence under Part 4 of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) (CLA). They said others were concurrent wrongdoers, including the waterproofer, parties involved in the manufacture, supply and installation of aluminium composite panels, the architect, the principal certifying authority and the local council. If that defence succeeded, each defendant would be liable only for the share of the loss a court considered just, having regard to its own responsibility.

The owners corporation applied to have those defences struck out. The primary judge refused, the NSW Court of Appeal allowed the owners corporation's appeal, and the defendants appealed to the High Court. The appeal was decided on the pleadings. The defects claim itself has not been determined, and the defendants' liability for the defects has not been established.

03 What the High Court decided

On 11 December 2024 the High Court dismissed the appeal by a 4:3 majority. The majority comprised Gageler CJ and Gleeson, Jagot and Beech-Jones JJ. Gordon, Edelman and Steward JJ dissented.

The majority's reasoning turned on three provisions working together. Section 39 of the DBP Act makes the section 37 duty non-delegable. Section 5Q of the CLA provides that liability for breach of a non-delegable duty is to be determined as if it were vicarious liability for the negligence of the person to whom the work was entrusted. Section 39(a) of the CLA provides that Part 4 does not prevent a person being held vicariously liable for a proportion of an apportionable claim for which another person is liable.

Read together, those provisions meant that a developer or head contractor which delegated or entrusted construction work to others remained responsible for that work. It could not reduce its liability to the owner by naming the people it had engaged as concurrent wrongdoers.

The decision does not make every developer or builder automatically liable for every defect. An owner must still prove that the defendant carried out construction work, that it failed to take reasonable care, that the failure caused the defects and the amount of the loss.

04 What the decision left open

Pafburn is about the parties who delegated or entrusted the work. It does not decide that proportionate liability has no role in any DBP Act claim.

The position of parties lower in the chain, and of those who do not usually delegate their work, such as some engineers, project managers and certifiers, was not resolved. Commentators have suggested those parties may still be able to argue that liability should be apportioned with other wrongdoers. That question will turn on the pleadings, on who entrusted what to whom and on future decisions.

It is also important to separate the causes of action. Many defect claims combine a DBP Act claim with claims for breach of contract or of the statutory warranties in the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW). Whether apportionment is available can differ from one cause of action to another, and the pleading of each matters.

05 What it means for developers and head contractors

Following Pafburn, a developer or head contractor facing a section 37 claim should assume that, if breach and loss are proven, it may be liable for the whole of the owner's loss arising from work it delegated or entrusted to others, even where that work was physically performed by a subcontractor.

The owner can recover the full amount from the party at the top of the chain and leave it to pursue everyone else. If the subcontractor responsible has since been wound up, has no insurance or cannot pay, the developer or head contractor bears that shortfall.

That shifts the focus of a defect claim. The questions are no longer only "how much of this is ours?" but "who can we recover from, on what basis, and will they be able to pay?" It also affects settlement. An owners corporation that knows proportionate liability is unavailable against the developer and head contractor will negotiate accordingly.

06 Recovering from subcontractors and consultants

Pafburn does not prevent a developer or head contractor from recovering its loss from the people who did the defective work. It changes how that recovery happens: through cross-claims or separate proceedings, rather than by reducing what the owner can recover.

Depending on the contracts and the facts, the avenues may include:

  • claims for breach of the subcontract or consultancy agreement, including defects and warranty provisions;
  • claims under contractual indemnities;
  • negligence or DBP Act claims against designers, engineers and other construction professionals; and
  • claims for contribution under section 5 of the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946 (NSW) against another party liable for the same damage.

For example, a head contractor found liable to an owners corporation for failed waterproofing may seek to recover from the waterproofing subcontractor. Whether that succeeds will depend on the subcontract terms, the evidence of what the subcontractor did and did not do, and whether the subcontractor or its insurer can meet the claim.

07 Time limits and changing legislation

Cross-claims need to be identified early. Building actions in New South Wales are subject to a 10-year long-stop limitation period under section 6.20 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW), measured from the completion of the work, and contribution claims have their own limitation rules. Recent NSW authority indicates that the long-stop can also catch contribution claims. A defendant that waits to see how the owner's case develops may find its own claims out of time.

The legislation is also changing. The Building (Approvals and Practitioners) Act 2026 (NSW), assented to in August 2026, is set to restructure parts of this framework when it commences. Readers should check whether the relevant parts have commenced before relying on this article.

08 Practical steps

  • Map every party to whom construction work was delegated or entrusted, and under which contract.
  • Check the solvency, licensing and insurance position of each subcontractor and consultant now, not at trial.
  • Review subcontract and consultancy indemnities, warranties, defects provisions and notice requirements.
  • Require evidence of current insurance from subcontractors and consultants, and keep it on file.
  • Diarise limitation dates for cross-claims and contribution claims from the start of the dispute.
  • Preserve construction records: inspection and test plans, photographs, variations, site diaries and correspondence.
  • Reassess settlement value with apportionment off the table for delegated work.

For owners corporations, the decision is a reason to consider carefully which parties to sue and on what basis. It does not remove the need to prove breach and loss with proper expert evidence, or to act within time. Damages for defects raise their own issues, discussed in our article on rectification costs and diminution in value.

09 How GopherWood Lawyers can help

Defect disputes after Pafburn are as much about recovery as about defence. The earlier the chain of responsibility is mapped and the cross-claims identified, the better the position of the party at the top of it.

GopherWood Lawyers acts for developers, head contractors, subcontractors, consultants and owners corporations in building defect disputes. We advise on DBP Act claims and defences, proportionate liability, cross-claims and contribution, indemnity and insurance recovery, and the resolution of construction litigation. Learn more about our builder, developer and contractor litigation work, or contact GopherWood Lawyers to discuss your matter.

This article provides general information about the law in New South Wales as at 10 November 2026. It is not legal advice. Outcomes depend on the facts, the pleadings and the contracts in each matter.

10 Sources and further reading

  1. High Court of Australia: Pafburn Pty Limited v The Owners - Strata Plan No 84674 [2024] HCA 49.
  2. The Owners - Strata Plan No 84674 v Pafburn Pty Ltd [2023] NSWCA 301.
  3. Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020 (NSW): especially ss 36 to 41.
  4. Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW): especially s 5Q and Part 4, including ss 34, 35 and 39.
  5. Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946 (NSW): s 5.
  6. Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW): ss 6.19 and 6.20.
  7. Colin Biggers & Paisley: High Court dismisses Pafburn appeal, 11 December 2024.