Once defects are proven, the argument usually moves to money. An owner wants the cost of putting the work right. The builder or developer says the owner is entitled to something far smaller: the amount by which the defects have reduced the property's value.

The gap between those two numbers can be large. Rectifying defective façade work might cost $500,000, while a valuer might say the defects have reduced the building's market value by $150,000. Which measure applies can decide whether a claim is worth pursuing at all.

Australian law starts from the cost of rectification, but only where the work is necessary and reasonable. This article explains how courts approach that question, what happens when rectification is not reasonable, and the evidence that usually decides the result.

01 Two ways to measure the loss

Rectification cost is the reasonable cost of the work needed to bring the building into line with what the contract, or the relevant legal obligations, required. Where defective waterproofing has let water into an apartment building, that may include removing finishes, replacing membranes and reinstating the affected areas.

Diminution in value is the difference between what the property is worth with the defects and what it would have been worth if the work had been done properly.

The two measures answer different questions. Rectification gives the owner the building it bargained for. Diminution in value compensates the owner for the property being worth less. Courts generally prefer the first, subject to an important limit.

02 The starting point: Bellgrove v Eldridge

The leading authority remains the High Court's decision in Bellgrove v Eldridge (1954) 90 CLR 613. A builder constructed a house with foundations that did not comply with the contract, using concrete and mortar mixes so lean that the house was likely to become gravely unstable. The evidence showed that the only satisfactory remedy was to demolish the house and rebuild it.

The Court held that the owner was entitled to the cost of demolition and reconstruction. The measure of loss is the cost of the work needed to produce conformity with the contract, provided two conditions are met: the work must be necessary to produce that conformity, and it must be a reasonable course to adopt.

The Court illustrated the limit with an example. If a contract called for walls of second-hand bricks and the builder used new, first-quality bricks instead, the owner could not recover the cost of demolishing the walls and rebuilding them in second-hand bricks. That would be quite unreasonable.

The Court also treated it as immaterial that the owner might not actually rebuild. The owner was entitled to compensation for the builder's failure to perform, assessed on the proper measure.

03 Cost can far exceed value: Tabcorp

The High Court returned to these principles in Tabcorp Holdings Ltd v Bowen Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 8. The case concerned a lease rather than a building contract, but it is now central to defect claims.

The tenant of a Melbourne office building demolished and replaced the building's high-quality foyer without the landlord's consent, in breach of the lease. The trial judge awarded $34,820, largely reflecting the small difference in the property's value. The Full Court of the Federal Court increased the award to about $1.38 million, made up of about $580,000 for restoring the foyer and about $800,000 for rent lost during the restoration period. The High Court dismissed the tenant's appeal.

The decision confirms that the innocent party is to be placed, so far as money can do it, in the position it would have been in if the contract had been performed. The fact that restoration costs far more than the loss in market value does not, by itself, make restoration unreasonable. A defendant cannot defeat a rectification claim simply by showing that the building is worth much the same either way.

04 When rectification is not reasonable: the Chocolate Factory case

The limit is real, and Westpoint Management Ltd v Chocolate Factory Apartments Ltd [2007] NSWCA 253 shows how it can catch a claimant out.

A developer converted a former chocolate factory at Stanmore into 87 apartments and sold them. It then sued the builder for defects, including skirting boards with a different profile from the one specified. About 3,500 lineal metres had been installed. The difference in material cost was roughly $350 across the project, but the developer claimed about $112,815 to remove and replace the boards.

The referee found that rectification was not reasonable. No purchaser had complained about the profile, the work would cause major disruption to occupants and there was no evidence that the sales had been affected. The developer had also run its case solely on rectification cost and led no evidence of any reduction in value. The result was that it recovered nothing for that item, and the Court of Appeal did not disturb the finding.

The Court also accepted that the developer's sale of the apartments was not, of itself, a bar to recovering rectification costs, although it could be relevant to whether rectification was reasonable. The lesson is practical: a claimant who relies only on rectification cost takes a risk if reasonableness is genuinely in issue.

05 Not always a choice between two numbers

A 2025 Victorian decision is a useful reminder that the two measures are not the only options. In Stanley v EWH Constructions West Pty Ltd [2025] VSC 699, a garage floor had not been built at the level the contract required, which mattered because the owners wanted to reverse their caravan through the garage. Correcting it would have meant demolishing and rebuilding the house.

The Supreme Court upheld the tribunal's refusal to award the cost of demolition and rebuilding as disproportionate, but varied the damages order. Commentary on the decision notes that an owner who cannot recover either rectification cost or a reduction in value is not necessarily left without a remedy, and that damages for matters such as loss of amenity may be available in an appropriate case.

06 Residential building work in NSW

For residential building work in New South Wales, the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW) adds another layer. Section 48MA requires a court or tribunal determining a building claim involving defective work to have regard to the principle that rectification of the defective work by the responsible party is the preferred outcome.

That principle is not mandatory. A court or the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal can make a money order instead where the circumstances justify it, for example where the owner has good reason not to allow the builder back on site. An owner who wants money rather than a work order needs evidence directed to that question, not only evidence about the defects.

Many defect claims are also brought under the statutory duty of care in the Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020 (NSW), which entitles an owner to damages as if the duty were established by the common law. The reasonableness of the proposed rectification remains central to the size of those claims. Who bears the loss among developers, builders and subcontractors is a separate question, discussed in our article on the High Court's decision in Pafburn.

07 The evidence that decides quantum

Damages for defects are usually won or lost on expert evidence. The evidence typically needed includes:

  • a building consultant's or engineer's report identifying each defect, its cause and its extent;
  • a proposed scope and method of rectification, explaining why it is necessary;
  • a quantity surveyor's assessment of the reasonable cost of that scope;
  • analysis of alternative, less intrusive methods and whether they would achieve conformity; and
  • valuation evidence of any reduction in value, as a fallback where reasonableness is contested.

Claimants should be able to show why the chosen scope is needed and that the cost is properly supported. Defendants should test whether the scope goes beyond what is needed, whether a cheaper method would achieve conformity, and whether the claim includes betterment, such as upgrades the original contract never required.

08 Other losses

Defects can cause losses beyond the cost of the work itself. Depending on the cause of action and the evidence, an owner may also claim:

  • rent lost while rectification work is carried out;
  • temporary accommodation and relocation costs;
  • the reasonable cost of investigating and reporting on the defects; and
  • other financial losses caused by the defective work.

Each item must be proven and must satisfy the rules on causation, remoteness and mitigation. The same loss cannot be recovered twice under different headings.

09 How GopherWood Lawyers can help

The measure of damages is often the most contested part of a defects case, and it is shaped by decisions made long before trial: which experts to retain, what scope they cost and whether valuation evidence is obtained.

GopherWood Lawyers acts for owners corporations, property owners, developers and builders in building defect disputes. We advise on liability and quantum, coordinate building, engineering, quantity surveying and valuation evidence, and run and defend claims in the courts and the Tribunal. Learn more about our building defects and construction defect litigation work, or contact GopherWood Lawyers to discuss your matter.

This article provides general information about the law in New South Wales as at 10 November 2026. It is not legal advice. The proper measure of damages depends on the facts, the cause of action and the evidence in each case.

10 Sources and further reading

  1. Bellgrove v Eldridge [1954] HCA 36; (1954) 90 CLR 613.
  2. High Court of Australia: Tabcorp Holdings Ltd v Bowen Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 8.
  3. Bowen Investments Pty Ltd v Tabcorp Holdings Ltd [2008] FCAFC 38.
  4. Westpoint Management Ltd v Chocolate Factory Apartments Ltd [2007] NSWCA 253.
  5. Allens: commentary on Stanley v EWH Constructions West Pty Ltd [2025] VSC 699, February 2026.
  6. Home Building Act 1989 (NSW): especially ss 18B, 48MA and 48O.
  7. Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020 (NSW): s 37.