Wage theft is now a criminal risk for Australian employers. Since 1 January 2025, intentionally failing to pay certain employee entitlements when due can attract imprisonment and substantial fines under section 327A of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). An underpayment of wages is not automatically a crime, but it still requires prompt attention.

For directors, business owners, HR managers and payroll teams, the distinction matters. An incorrect award classification may begin as an honest error. Continuing a payment practice after warnings about unpaid overtime can raise different questions about knowledge, recklessness and intention. Calling the issue a software problem does not answer those questions.

The immediate priorities are to stop further shortfalls, preserve evidence, obtain legal advice and work out what employees are owed. Repayment matters, but does not retrospectively make an intentional failure to pay on time lawful.

Natasha Verma, Associate, explains the federal wage theft laws Australia’s employers need to understand, including personal exposure, the small business code, self-reporting and responding to a Fair Work Ombudsman underpayment investigation. This article is written for employers and businesses, not as advice to employees.

01 What is wage theft under Australian law?

“Wage theft” is commonly used to describe employees being denied wages or entitlements. The federal criminal offence is more precise. Section 327A was inserted by the Fair Work Legislation Amendment (Closing Loopholes) Act 2023 (Cth) and commenced on 1 January 2025. It targets intentional underpayment, not every payroll discrepancy.

The prosecution must establish that an employer was required to pay an amount to an employee, on their behalf or for their benefit, under the Act, a fair work instrument or a continued transitional instrument. Modern awards and enterprise agreements are important examples. A purely contractual promise should not automatically be treated as an amount within this offence: identify its legal source.

The employer must engage in conduct that results in failure to pay the required amount in full on or before its due date. Intention applies both to the conduct and to that result. An intentional omission can matter as much as an active instruction. Deliberately withholding an overtime payment is not different in principle merely because nobody changed the employee’s base hourly rate.

There is an important qualification. Section 327A(3) applies absolute liability to the elements concerning the payment obligation and whether an exclusion applies. It is unsafe to simplify the offence as requiring proof that the employer knew every detail of the award or correctly understood the law. The prosecution must nevertheless prove the required intention concerning conduct and non-payment beyond reasonable doubt.

The offence applies to intentional underpayments after commencement, including those forming part of an earlier course of conduct. Pre-2025 payroll history can still matter to civil recovery and evidence. Employers should separate the relevant periods rather than assuming that an old payroll configuration is outside the criminal regime forever.

Does wage theft include superannuation?

Certain superannuation contributions can be covered where the obligation arises under the Act or a relevant instrument. There is no blanket exclusion for everything commonly called “super guarantee”. Conversely, an amount arising solely under separate taxation legislation is not brought into section 327A merely because it concerns an employee.

Section 327A(2) contains a narrower exclusion. Where the employee or employer is within the national system only through the specified State referral provisions, excluded amounts include superannuation contributions and specified long service, victim-of-crime, jury service and emergency services leave payments. The employer’s legal structure and basis of federal coverage therefore matter. Superannuation guarantee charge and related tax obligations require separate analysis.

02 Is an honest underpayment of wages wage theft?

Not for the purposes of the federal criminal offence merely because a shortfall occurred. The Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) expressly distinguishes honest mistakes from intentional underpayment. Recklessness alone is also insufficient for section 327A, although it can support the separate serious civil contravention regime.

These categories turn on evidence, not the label in an investigation report. Relevant material may include payroll change requests, employee complaints, award advice, audit findings, rostering records and emails about labour costs. A written instruction to remove overtime despite recorded hours looks different from an isolated transcription error promptly corrected.

Underpayment categories and employer exposure
CategoryIllustrative conductPotential consequences
Honest mistakeAn incorrect payroll setting causes an unintended shortfall, discovered during reconciliation.Back payments and possible ordinary civil enforcement. The mistake alone does not establish criminal intention.
Knowing or reckless civil contraventionManagement knows of a breach, or takes an unjustifiable substantial risk that it will occur.Potential serious civil contravention and higher penalties. Criminal liability still requires the criminal elements.
Intentional criminal underpaymentAn employer deliberately withholds required payments by their due date.Possible section 327A prosecution, fines and, for individuals, imprisonment.

The distinctions come from sections 327A and 557A of the Act and the FWO’s criminal prosecution guidance. These examples are illustrative, not findings about any business.

An employer should not treat its first mistake as permission to continue. Once a credible concern emerges, the response becomes part of the evidence. Record what is uncertain, who is resolving it and what interim controls will prevent another shortfall. Obtain advice about disputed entitlements rather than repeatedly postponing the issue until the next payroll upgrade.

03 Can you go to jail for wage theft?

Yes. An individual convicted under section 327A faces up to 10 years’ imprisonment, a fine, or both. A body corporate faces a fine. These are statutory maximums, not automatic sentences, and liability must first be established.

Where the court can determine the underpayment amount for the offence, the maximum fine is the greater of three times that amount and the relevant fixed penalty-unit amount. For an individual, the fixed amount is 5,000 penalty units. For a body corporate, it is 25,000 penalty units. The three-times calculation therefore applies to individuals as well as companies.

If the court cannot determine the underpayment amount, the maximum fine is the fixed amount: 5,000 units for an individual or 25,000 units for a company. An inability to reconstruct the shortfall is not a way to avoid substantial exposure.

The Australian Financial Security Authority’s published Commonwealth penalty-unit table records a value of $364 from 1 July 2026, following $330 for the preceding relevant period. At $364, the fixed amounts are $1.82 million for an individual and $9.1 million for a company. At $330, they were $1.65 million and $8.25 million respectively. Use the value applicable to the offence, not simply the date of the investigation or sentence.

Section 327A also contains course-of-conduct aggregation rules. Where the statutory conditions apply to multiple offences, the legislation treats them as a single offence for the specified penalty calculations and addresses aggregation of ascertainable underpayments. Neither a simple per-payslip multiplication nor a single business-wide figure will necessarily reflect the correct approach.

04 Can directors, HR managers and payroll staff be personally liable?

A company structure does not remove personal exposure. Equally, holding a directorship or processing a pay run does not automatically make someone criminally liable. The person’s conduct, involvement and relevant state of mind must be examined separately from the company’s position.

The Commonwealth Criminal Code contains rules governing corporate criminal responsibility, including attribution of conduct and fault. Corporate culture can be relevant to attribution. A paper policy requiring lawful payment should not be confused with evidence that the business actually identifies and corrects unlawful practices. Instructions, approval pathways and the treatment of internal warnings deserve close attention.

Criminal accessorial liability also requires separate consideration where someone assists an intentional underpayment. Directors, managers, HR personnel and external payroll providers should not assume that only the employing entity can face proceedings. A person who merely receives information is not necessarily in the same position as someone who directs or knowingly assists the conduct.

For civil proceedings, section 550 of the Act expressly addresses involvement. It includes aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring a contravention, inducing it, being knowingly concerned in it, or conspiring to effect it. Personal civil exposure can arise even when the employer is insolvent or has ceased trading.

Employers should identify conflicts early. The company and a manager who approved a disputed practice may need separate advice. Do not ask potentially implicated staff to agree a common account, delete discussions or conduct interviews designed to protect a particular individual. Preserve the evidence and establish a properly supervised investigation.

05 Who investigates wage theft and brings a prosecution?

The FWO investigates suspected criminal underpayments and can refer suitable matters to the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions or the Australian Federal Police. Section 327C provides that proceedings for the offence, and specified related offences, may be commenced only by the Director of Public Prosecutions or the Australian Federal Police.

The FWO is therefore not simply issuing a criminal fine after a payroll inspection. Investigation, referral, prosecution and conviction are different stages. Its criminal prosecution guidance identifies evidentiary and public-interest considerations, with further detail in its Compliance and Enforcement Policy.

A business receiving an information request should establish what power is being used, the response deadline and whether the request concerns civil issues, suspected criminal conduct or both. Preserve responsive material immediately. Obtain advice about compulsory production, interview requests, privilege and the accuracy of proposed responses rather than assuming every interaction is an informal payroll discussion.

Section 327C separately permits criminal proceedings within six years after commission of the offence. That is not the same provision as the civil recovery limitation. A payment review should map payment due dates, the individuals involved and relevant records across the affected period.

So far the offence has been slow to reach court. In May 2026, FWO officials told a Senate inquiry that 39 suspected matters had been assessed under the new laws, four had become full investigations and none had yet been referred to police or prosecutors. In late October 2026, the Fair Work Ombudsman told Senate Estimates that no matter had yet been referred to the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions. Employers should not read that as a sign the offence is unused in practice: investigations are under way, the FWO has said criminal cases take time to build, and the six-year window means conduct occurring now can be prosecuted years later.

06 How does the small business wage compliance code work?

The Minister’s Voluntary Small Business Wage Compliance Code commenced on 1 January 2025. It is directed to small business employers, generally those with fewer than 15 employees at the relevant time. Employees of associated entities count. Casual employees count if employed on a regular and systematic basis. This is a headcount issue, not a full-time-equivalent calculation.

The FWO explains that a small business complies with the Code if it did not intend to underpay employees, assessed through the relevant factors. Practical matters include efforts to establish correct pay, obtaining information or advice, dealing with concerns and correcting errors. Keep evidence of those steps rather than relying on a general assertion of good intentions.

Under section 327B, if the FWO is satisfied that the employer complied with the Code in relation to the failure, it must not refer the resulting conduct for possible criminal prosecution. It must give written notice of that decision. The provision also prevents entry into a cooperation agreement for that conduct.

This is not a licence to pay below an award and not a cancellation of arrears. Civil proceedings, compliance notices and enforceable undertakings remain possible. Nor should employers describe the Code as universal immunity from every authority or every offence: its statutory protection concerns specified action by the FWO.

For a small employer, a useful file includes the award and classification assessment, advice received, payroll checks, complaint responses and evidence of remediation. A business close to the employee threshold should check associated entities before assuming it qualifies.

07 Should an employer self-report an underpayment to the FWO?

Self-reporting deserves prompt consideration, but it should follow an informed assessment rather than a hurried admission. Employers need to understand the affected conduct, immediate controls, available records and possible personal exposure. Legal advice should not become an excuse to postpone correcting known shortfalls.

A cooperation agreement is a separate statutory mechanism. Under sections 717A and 717B, the FWO may enter a written agreement covering specified conduct that the person has reported as potentially constituting the offence or its physical elements. It is discretionary, not an entitlement obtained by sending an email headed “voluntary disclosure”.

Relevant considerations include whether disclosure was voluntary, frank and complete; the nature and detail of the disclosure; cooperation and commitment to continued cooperation; the gravity and circumstances of the conduct; and compliance history. A credible remediation plan should explain how the employer will establish the amount owed and demonstrate that the fix works.

While an agreement is in force, the FWO must not refer that person’s covered conduct for possible criminal prosecution. Civil proceedings remain possible, and other people’s conduct can still be referred. Identify the parties and scope carefully: a company’s agreement does not automatically protect every director or manager.

The FWO’s cooperation guidance and Compliance and Enforcement Policy should inform any approach. Self-reporting, repayment and cooperation can influence enforcement decisions, but none should be described as guaranteeing no penalty. Before disclosure, settle who will communicate, how errors will be corrected and how continuing updates will be verified.

08 What civil consequences remain for underpayment of wages?

The criminal offence sits alongside civil enforcement. An honest error can still involve contraventions of the National Employment Standards, a modern award, an enterprise agreement or payment obligations. The business may need to pay arrears and interest, defend proceedings and repair its payroll controls even where criminal intention cannot be proved.

The Closing Loopholes reforms increased civil exposure, including higher maximum penalties for specified contraventions by employers outside the small business category. Sections 539 and 546 must be read together, including applicable multipliers and underpayment-linked provisions. There is no single civil maximum suitable for every payroll failure, employer and period.

Section 557A now treats a contravention as serious where the person knowingly contravened the provision or was reckless as to whether the contravention would occur. Recklessness involves awareness of a substantial risk and taking that risk unjustifiably in the known circumstances. The former requirement for a systematic pattern is no longer part of that test.

An inspector may issue a compliance notice under section 716 requiring specified remedial action, including calculating and paying underpayments, and evidence of compliance. Read the notice immediately. Ignoring it can create a further enforcement problem; disputing it requires consideration of the statutory review process, not silence.

Under section 715, the FWO can accept an enforceable undertaking. Undertakings can involve repayment, independent reviews, reporting and compliance measures. They are not simply informal promises. Court proceedings may also produce payment orders and interest. Civil and criminal penalty proceedings have statutory interaction rules, so it is inaccurate to assume all available punishments will simply accumulate for identical conduct.

For civil recovery, section 544 generally requires the relevant application within six years after the contravention. Section 545(5) also limits underpayment orders by reference to amounts relating to periods more than six years before proceedings commenced. Do not substitute the discovery date for the payment history or assume ongoing discussions stop time running.

09 What payroll records should employers keep?

Section 535 requires prescribed employee records to be made and kept for seven years. Section 536 requires a payslip within one working day of payment for work. The regulations prescribe detailed information requirements. A payroll system’s standard output is not proof that those requirements have been met.

Retain source records as well as totals: rosters, actual hours, overtime approvals, classifications, rate changes, leave transactions and relevant correspondence. Check whether payroll exports preserve historical configurations when software is replaced. Without that information, reconstructing the reason for a shortfall becomes slower and more expensive.

Section 557C can shift the evidentiary burden in specified civil proceedings. Where the employer failed to meet relevant record or payslip obligations, it can bear the burden of disproving an allegation concerning the matter those records should address. There is a reasonable-excuse exception. This is not a general reversal of the criminal burden of proof.

Do not recreate documents as though they were contemporaneous records. Preserve originals, record reconstruction assumptions and distinguish estimated hours from verified data. A remediation exercise should improve the evidence, not obscure how it was assembled.

10 What should employers do when an underpayment is discovered?

  1. Contain the problem. Identify the affected rule or practice and implement a checked interim solution. Preserve system settings before changing them so investigators can understand what happened.
  2. Obtain legal advice and preserve evidence. Consider a lawyer-directed investigation for the dominant purpose of legal advice or anticipated litigation. Privilege is not automatic because a lawyer is copied into an email. Existing business records do not become privileged merely by sending them to a lawyer.
  3. Define the review. Identify entities, employees, instruments, classifications, pay periods and payment due dates. Test ordinary hours, overtime, penalties, allowances, leave and superannuation separately. Do not assume an above-award salary absorbs every entitlement.
  4. Calculate and validate. Reconcile source hours with payroll and bank data. Document assumptions, review sample calculations and extend the review if the sample reveals a wider problem. Avoid offsetting one period’s apparent surplus against another period’s shortfall without advice.
  5. Remediate accurately. Arrange back payments, assess interest and associated superannuation and tax treatment, and explain calculations clearly. Include former employees. Keep evidence of payment and unresolved contact attempts.
  6. Assess reporting and personal exposure. Consider the Code, cooperation agreements and the FWO’s enforcement approach. Address possible conflicts between the company and individuals before interviews or disclosures.
  7. Report to the board and verify the fix. Allocate responsibility, resources and deadlines. Provide directors with the scope, estimated exposure, uncertainties and testing results. Recheck later pay runs rather than closing the issue when the software change goes live.

Communications should distinguish established facts from working estimates. Promise a realistic update date, provide a contact point and avoid describing an incomplete review as a final clearance. A clean calculation and an accountable decision trail are more useful than confident assurances unsupported by records.

11 What do recent underpayment outcomes show employers?

The FWO’s 2024 to 2025 undertaking register records that Griffith University agreed in June 2025 to complete more than $8.34 million in payments, including interest and superannuation, to 5,457 staff. It also records La Trobe University’s March 2025 undertaking involving more than $10.77 million, including superannuation and interest, for more than 6,700 staff.

In December 2025, the FWO announced the University of Tasmania’s undertaking involving completion of more than $21.4 million in payments, including interest and superannuation, to over 10,000 staff. The announcement identified minimum engagement failures, penalty rates and other entitlements, together with governance and payroll deficiencies. It also recorded a $175,000 contrition payment.

These are enforceable undertaking outcomes, not section 327A convictions or proof of criminal intention. Their practical lesson is that ordinary payroll rules can produce extensive liabilities when repeated across a workforce. Self-identification does not remove the need for independent checking, repayment and ongoing compliance measures.

12 Wage theft FAQs for employers

What is wage theft compared with an ordinary payroll error?

The federal criminal offence requires intentional conduct and an intentional failure to pay covered amounts when due. An ordinary error can still require repayment and expose an employer to civil enforcement without satisfying the criminal test.

Can you go to jail for wage theft if the company employs the staff?

Potentially, if the legal basis for personal criminal liability is established. Incorporation is not automatic protection for deliberate participation. Equally, a director is not guilty simply because the company underpaid someone.

Do wage theft laws in Australia cover small businesses?

Yes. Small businesses have access to the Voluntary Small Business Wage Compliance Code protections where the statutory requirements are met. Being small does not excuse unpaid entitlements or prevent civil enforcement.

Will repaying stolen wages prevent prosecution?

Repayment is important but does not automatically erase an offence already committed. “Stolen wages” is a broad description, not a substitute for analysing section 327A. Consider remediation, disclosure and any available statutory protection together.

What happens in a Fair Work Ombudsman underpayment investigation?

The FWO may seek records and explanations, examine payment obligations and consider enforcement options. Employers should preserve evidence, check response obligations and obtain advice about the investigation’s scope before making substantive representations.

Can an employer rely on its payroll provider?

Outsourcing does not transfer the employer’s payment obligations. Obtain the provider’s records and assumptions, check contractual responsibilities and verify the correction. Whether another person is also liable is a separate question.

13 How GopherWood Lawyers can assist

GopherWood Lawyers acts for employers and businesses in employment disputes. Our underpayment and wage claims defence work includes assessing disputed entitlements, evidence, response options and remediation issues. We do not act for employees.

We assist businesses with regulatory investigations, including responses to regulator inquiries. Where a payroll investigation raises separate senior management employment issues, our executive termination disputes service can address the employer’s position.

Employers and business representatives can call 02 9160 2157 or contact GopherWood Lawyers to discuss your legal options.

This article provides general information about Australian law as at 20 November 2026. It is not legal advice. The applicable instrument, payment dates, business structure and evidence of intention can materially change the assessment.

14 Sources and further reading

  1. Fair Work Act 2009, Federal Register of Legislation
  2. Fair Work Act 2009, July 2026 compilation, Volume 2
  3. Fair Work Act 2009, July 2026 compilation, Volume 3
  4. Fair Work Ombudsman, Criminal prosecution
  5. Fair Work Ombudsman, Criminalising wage underpayments and other issues
  6. Australian Financial Security Authority, Penalty units
  7. Fair Work Ombudsman, Voluntary Small Business Wage Compliance Code
  8. Fair Work Ombudsman, Cooperation agreements
  9. Fair Work Ombudsman, 2024 to 2025 enforceable undertakings
  10. Fair Work Ombudsman, University of Tasmania enforceable undertaking
  11. AAP: No criminal charges despite $49.5m wage theft blitz (4 May 2026)
  12. Workplace Express: Criminal wage theft offence still unused: FWO (30 October 2026)