Unfair contract terms are no longer just clauses a court can strike out. Since 9 November 2023, businesses have faced civil penalties for including unfair terms in covered standard form contracts and for applying or relying on them. A supplier's routine renewal email, price change or demand for an exit fee can expose weaknesses in a template used across thousands of customers.

The unfair contract terms small business protections reach well beyond dealings with large corporations. A small business issuing its own standard form contract can breach the law, even while receiving protection under a different supplier's agreement. Consumer contracts are also covered.

There are two important updates to older guidance: the ACL's fixed corporate penalty limb increased from $50 million to $100 million on 28 March 2026, and the financial services regime has different penalties and retains a $5 million upfront-price threshold for small business contracts.

Natasha Verma, Associate, explains what businesses should check, what makes a term unfair and what to do when a supplier insists that signing the contract ends the discussion.

01 What changed under the unfair contract terms laws?

The core rules for ordinary goods, services and land transactions appear in sections 23 to 28 of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth). Financial products and financial services are generally dealt with under sections 12BF to 12BM of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth), commonly called the ASIC Act.

The Treasury Laws Amendment (More Competition, Better Prices) Act 2022 (Cth) changed the consequences of unfair terms and expanded the small business protections. The relevant reforms commenced on 9 November 2023. They apply to contracts made or renewed on or after that date. Where an existing contract is varied on or after that date, the application rules bring the varied term within the reforms, with associated rules governing the assessment of the contract.

That distinction matters. An unchanged contract signed before commencement is not automatically exposed to the new penalty regime simply because someone reads it today. Equally, calling an arrangement an extension rather than a renewal does not settle its legal effect. Check the original agreement, subsequent correspondence and the mechanism by which the relationship continued.

Under ACL section 23(2A), a person contravenes the law by making a covered standard form contract containing an unfair term that the person proposed. Each unfair term proposed is a separate contravention. Section 23(2C) separately prohibits applying, relying on, or purporting to apply or rely on an unfair term. The ASIC Act contains corresponding prohibitions.

The common shorthand is that proposing, using or relying on unfair terms is prohibited. More precisely, the making-contract prohibition requires a contract to be made. Businesses should nevertheless review terms before sending them out, not wait for a customer to accept or complain.

02 Which consumer and small business contracts are covered?

Under ACL section 23, a consumer contract concerns the supply of goods or services, or the sale or grant of an interest in land, to an individual acquiring them wholly or predominantly for personal, domestic or household use or consumption. The UCT definition is not simply the same as every other ACL definition of a consumer.

A small business contract under the ACL concerns those same kinds of transactions and requires at least one party, when the contract is made, to satisfy either of these business tests:

  • It carries on a business and employs fewer than 100 people.
  • Its turnover for the relevant preceding income year is less than $10 million.

These are alternatives, not cumulative requirements. A business with 120 employees might qualify through turnover; a business with higher turnover might qualify through employee numbers. Regular and systematic casual employees count, and part-time employees count as the appropriate fraction of a full-time equivalent. Turnover is calculated under the statutory rules, not simply by selecting a convenient revenue figure from a management report.

The ACL no longer has an upfront contract-price cap for small business protection. Do not use the old value thresholds or the former employee test when assessing a contract covered by the reforms.

Financial services have an additional price cap

The ASIC Act uses the expanded employee or turnover alternatives, but a small business contract must also have an upfront price payable of no more than $5 million. For credit contracts, interest is disregarded when calculating that price. ASIC's guidance expressly distinguishes this cap from the ACL, where the monetary cap has been removed.

A sole trader's equipment purchase and the finance agreement funding that purchase may therefore require separate assessments. Identify what each contract actually supplies, who the contracting parties are and whether the applicable transaction falls within the financial services rules. Do not assume that every agreement in a commercial package has the same coverage.

03 What is a standard form contract if some terms were negotiated?

A standard form contract is commonly prepared in advance for repeated use, with the recipient having little meaningful scope to change its terms. Online subscription conditions, equipment hire agreements, service agreements and supplier trading terms are familiar examples. The label on the document is not decisive.

ACL section 27 creates a practical evidentiary advantage: if a party to proceedings alleges that a contract is standard form, it is presumed to be so unless another party proves otherwise. A supplier should therefore keep evidence of genuine negotiations rather than rely on a recital saying that every clause was freely negotiated.

The court must consider bargaining power, whether the contract was prepared before discussions, whether the recipient effectively had to accept or reject it, whether there was an effective opportunity to negotiate relevant terms, and whether the document reflects the particular customer or transaction. It must also consider whether the preparing party has made other contracts in the same or substantially similar terms and, if so, how many.

The reforms expressly recognise that limited choice does not necessarily prevent a contract being standard form. An opportunity to negotiate minor or insubstantial changes, to choose from options set by the other party, or evidence that someone else negotiated another contract does not settle the issue. The corresponding ASIC Act provision is section 12BK.

For example, letting a customer choose a monthly payment date and one of three service packages does not necessarily make liability exclusions or termination rights negotiable. An account manager's invitation to ask questions is also different from authority to agree to substantive changes.

04 What is an unfair contract term?

ACL section 24 sets out a three-limb test. A term is unfair if it causes a significant imbalance in the parties' contractual rights and obligations, is not reasonably necessary to protect the legitimate interests of the party advantaged by it, and would cause financial or other detriment to a party if applied or relied on. All three elements must be established.

Significant imbalance

Look at practical rights, not just matching words. A supplier might reserve immediate termination for any breach while requiring the customer to keep paying through prolonged service failures. That arrangement calls for closer examination. Different rights are not automatically unfair, because the parties may have different responsibilities and risks.

Reasonably necessary protection

The law presumes that a term is not reasonably necessary to protect the advantaged party's legitimate interests unless that party proves otherwise. Identify the actual interest and the evidence supporting it. A genuine need to recover committed third-party costs does not necessarily justify collecting every remaining subscription payment after early termination.

Detriment and transparency

Detriment need not already have occurred. The question includes what would happen if the term were used. Harm may be financial or otherwise, such as losing a meaningful opportunity to obtain replacement services.

The court must consider transparency and the contract as a whole. A transparent term is expressed in reasonably plain language, legible, presented clearly and readily available to the affected party. A hidden web link, dense cross-references or a renewal clause buried under an unrelated heading can matter.

Transparency is not a complete defence. A clearly written clause can still be unfair. Conversely, assess an apparent imbalance alongside genuine counterbalancing protections elsewhere in the agreement. The ASIC Act's corresponding test appears in section 12BG.

05 What are common unfair contract terms examples in Australia?

ACL section 25 provides examples of terms that may be unfair, including certain one-sided variation, termination, penalty and liability provisions. It is an indicative list, not a rule that every clause within those descriptions is invalid. The ASIC Act contains a corresponding list in section 12BH.

The following table is a review tool, not replacement drafting. A safer approach must still fit the transaction and satisfy the statutory test.

Common risky terms and approaches to reducing unfairness
TermRisk to checkSafer approach
Unilateral variationSupplier can change price, scope or conditions at any time without an effective response.Confine changes to identified reasons, give reasonable advance notice and allow an effective exit where appropriate.
Termination for convenienceSupplier can walk away immediately while the customer remains locked in.Use proportionate notice, address prepaid amounts and provide workable customer protections.
Broad indemnityCustomer bears losses caused by the supplier's own negligence or matters outside the customer's control.Connect liability to responsibility and causation, with appropriate exclusions and limits.
Automatic renewalLong renewal periods, a narrow cancellation window and no practical reminder.Give clear reminders, reasonable cancellation opportunities and proportionate renewal periods.
Liability exclusionSupplier excludes meaningful responsibility while retaining broad claims against the customer.Use justified limits, preserve non-excludable rights and address each party's actual risks.
Exit feesCharges apply regardless of actual loss, saved costs or the reason the contract ended.Link recovery to a supportable commercial interest and avoid disproportionate charges.

A right to cancel is not useful if cancellation itself triggers an excessive charge or if the change takes effect before notice reaches the customer. Review the combined effect of related clauses and the systems used to administer them.

06 Which terms and contracts are excluded from unfairness review?

ACL section 26 excludes a term from this review to the extent that it defines the contract's main subject matter, sets the upfront price payable, or is required or expressly permitted by Commonwealth, state or territory law. These are limited exclusions, not a general exemption for commercially important clauses.

The upfront price is broadly the disclosed consideration payable for the supply, sale or grant. It does not include other consideration contingent on a particular event occurring or not occurring. A future default charge does not become protected simply because it appears in a price schedule. Nor is every variation mechanism part of the excluded upfront price.

ACL section 28 excludes particular contracts, including specified shipping arrangements and company constitutions. Other statutory allocation rules also matter when financial products and services are involved. The ASIC Act has its own exclusions and qualifications, including particular life insurance and financial market arrangements.

Insurance needs care. UCT protection was extended from 5 April 2021 to relevant consumer and small business insurance contracts covered by the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth), subject to the application rules for making, renewal and variation. The unfairness regime is in the ASIC Act, operating alongside insurance legislation, not a separate UCT code in the Insurance Contracts Act. Special rules apply to insurance, including identifying the main subject matter. Obtain advice on the particular policy rather than assuming insurance is wholly excluded.

07 What are the unfair contract terms penalties now?

The applicable maximum depends on the legislation and when the contravention occurred. Under ACL section 224, the current corporate maximum for a UCT contravention is the greater of:

  • $100 million;
  • three times the value of the reasonably attributable benefit obtained by the corporation and related bodies corporate, if the court can determine that value; or
  • if that value cannot be determined, 30% of adjusted turnover during the statutory breach turnover period.

The fixed limb was previously $50 million. The Treasury Laws Amendment (Doubling Penalties for ACCC Enforcement) Act 2026 (Cth) increased it from 28 March 2026, with application to relevant conduct from commencement. The ACL maximum for a person other than a body corporate remains $2.5 million. Historical conduct requires checking the applicable version and application provisions.

The ASIC Act uses a different formula in section 12GBCA. For corporations, the maximum is the greatest of 50,000 penalty units, three times the determinable benefit derived and detriment avoided, or 10% of annual turnover, with the turnover limb capped at 2.5 million penalty units. For individuals, it is the greater of 5,000 penalty units or three times the determinable benefit derived and detriment avoided.

ASIC confirms that the Commonwealth penalty unit increased to $364 on 1 July 2026. For conduct attracting that unit value, the fixed ASIC Act limbs are therefore $18.2 million for corporations and $1.82 million for individuals. These are not universal caps: the alternative benefit and turnover calculations matter. The penalty-unit value at the time of the contravention must be checked.

Maximum penalties are not automatic awards. Courts assess the contraventions and relevant penalty principles. However, multiple unfair terms and their application across many contracts can create substantial exposure. A civil penalty is payable to the Commonwealth, not compensation paid directly to an affected customer.

08 What have courts and regulators done about unfair contract terms?

Earlier decisions show recurring drafting problems

In October 2017, the Federal Court declared eight terms in JJ Richards' small business contracts unfair and void by consent. The ACCC identified automatic renewal, unilateral price increases, charging for services not rendered in relevant circumstances and broad liability protection among the problems. This was a pre-penalty UCT outcome, not a monetary penalty judgment.

The Servcorp outcome in July 2018 concerned 12 terms used by two subsidiaries. The consent declarations addressed automatic renewal combined with unilateral price changes, unilateral termination, unreasonable liability provisions and retention of security deposits where customers did not request their return.

In August 2022, in proceedings brought by the ACCC against Fujifilm Business Innovation Australia, the Federal Court declared 38 terms in 11 types of small business contracts unfair and void. Orders also restrained enforcement and future use of the relevant terms. Automatic renewal, excessive exit fees and unilateral price increases featured in the ACCC's account. These earlier cases remain useful warnings, but their historical eligibility thresholds should not be applied to today's contracts.

A 2026 financial services penalty

ASIC's 2026 CashnGo announcement reports a $3.5 million Federal Court penalty against Venture 5 Group Pty Ltd, trading as CashnGo, concerning use of and reliance on unfair terms in more than 47,000 standard form small amount credit contracts. The admitted terms allowed automated account monitoring and repeated unscheduled withdrawal attempts after missed repayments, without advance notice of timing, frequency or amount and without an opt-out.

This is an actual penalty outcome under the financial services regime. It should not be confused with earlier declarations or an ACCC undertaking. The example also shows why payment collection software and operational instructions belong in a contract audit.

Not every challenged term is unfair

In Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Auto & General Insurance Company Limited [2025] FCAFC 76, the Full Federal Court dismissed ASIC's appeal concerning an insurance notification term. The decision illustrates the importance of construing the term in its contractual and statutory setting before applying the unfairness test.

Regulatory action also occurs outside judgments. In June 2025, the ACCC accepted a court-enforceable undertaking from Mable following admissions about unfair terms, including fee changes, deemed approval of service logs and liability provisions. An undertaking is not a court-imposed penalty. Likewise, allegations in newly commenced proceedings are not findings. Businesses should distinguish the procedural outcome before treating a media headline as a precedent.

09 What happens if a contract term is unfair?

An unfair term in a covered standard form contract is void under ACL section 23. The balance of the agreement continues if it can operate without that term. A signature does not cure unfairness, but the legislation does not ordinarily cancel the entire agreement merely because one clause fails.

Courts can make declarations and injunctions. The ACL also provides orders addressing existing or likely loss and powers directed to declared unfair terms, including preventing their future use or reliance. Depending on the statutory basis and circumstances, relief may include refusing enforcement, varying arrangements, refunds or compensation. The ASIC Act provides corresponding enforcement and remedial mechanisms.

The appropriate application depends on who seeks relief, the relevant contract, the conduct and the loss. A regulator's penalty proceeding is not a substitute for assessing an individual customer's recovery claim. Nor does a complaint automatically suspend payment obligations or stop a supplier commencing debt recovery.

Before withholding money, terminating services or asserting that a clause is void, obtain advice about the disputed term and the obligations that remain. Interim relief may be important where termination, collection or an automatic renewal is imminent.

10 How should businesses audit their standard form contracts?

  1. Locate the entire contract set. Collect quotations, order forms, online conditions, schedules, incorporated policies, renewal notices and industry-specific templates. Include versions still operating with existing customers.
  2. Map coverage and dates. Record the parties, purpose, employee or turnover evidence, governing regime and any relevant price cap. Identify making, renewal and variation dates rather than assuming every document has the same treatment.
  3. Identify one-sided powers. Review variation, suspension, termination, indemnities, liability limits, evidence clauses, payment deductions, renewal and exit charges together. Ask what happens during an actual service failure.
  4. Document legitimate interests. Keep evidence of committed costs, operational risks and why narrower protections would not adequately address them. A preference for maximum flexibility is not evidence by itself.
  5. Test the customer's practical options. Check notice delivery, cancellation steps, refund arrangements and whether customers can leave before a detrimental change takes effect.
  6. Check presentation and access. Use plain language and clear headings. Ensure linked documents are available before agreement and preserve the accepted version.
  7. Change systems as well as drafting. Update sales scripts, billing rules, automated renewals, collection workflows and staff authority. Do not keep enforcing a removed term through an old process.
  8. Control future changes. Allocate responsibility for template approval, periodic review and escalated complaints. Record why substantive negotiation requests were accepted or refused.

Prioritise clauses already generating complaints, high-volume consumer contracts and agreements used with businesses likely to meet either small business test. A generic saving clause saying that the law prevails does not replace reviewing the substantive rights being asserted.

11 What can a small business do about an unfair supplier contract?

Keep the signed agreement, earlier versions, renewal messages, invoices and screenshots of online terms. Record who offered the document, what changes were requested and what the supplier said. Preserve evidence of business size at the relevant time and the financial or operational consequences of the disputed clause.

Raise a focused objection. Identify the clause, explain the imbalance and ask what legitimate interest requires that breadth. Propose a concrete change, such as advance notice of price increases and an exit without an additional charge. General statements that the whole contract feels unfair are less useful than explaining what the clause permits.

If the supplier threatens enforcement, ask it to identify the contractual basis and pause the disputed step while the issue is reviewed. Do not assume it must agree. Consider advice about negotiation, dispute resolution or urgent court relief. Complaints may be made to the ACCC or ASIC as appropriate; regulatory reporting does not mean the regulator will resolve your individual dispute.

For eligible financial complaints, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority may provide another avenue, subject to its jurisdiction. Check available processes promptly, especially where a demand, renewal deadline or interruption to essential services is approaching.

12 FAQs about unfair contract terms

What is an unfair contract term in Australia?

It is a term meeting all three statutory elements: significant imbalance, lack of reasonable necessity to protect legitimate interests, and detriment if applied or relied on. Transparency and the contract as a whole must also be considered.

Do unfair contract terms small business laws protect sole traders?

They can. Sole traders are not excluded because of their business structure. The transaction, business eligibility, standard form character and applicable regime must still meet the relevant requirements.

Are automatic renewal clauses illegal?

Not automatically. Notice, renewal length, cancellation opportunities, price changes and the commercial justification all matter. A hidden rollover with a narrow opt-out window is a clear review priority.

Can I challenge a standard form contract after signing it?

Yes. Signing does not remove statutory UCT protection. However, obtain advice before treating the entire contract as unenforceable or stopping performance, because unaffected obligations may continue.

What are the unfair contract terms penalties for companies?

Under the current ACL, the corporate maximum uses the $100 million, benefit and adjusted-turnover formula explained above. The ASIC Act has a different penalty-unit, benefit and turnover formula. The date of the contravention matters.

Does negotiating the price stop a contract being standard form?

No. Negotiating price or choosing a package does not necessarily establish an effective opportunity to negotiate the remaining conditions. The court considers the statutory factors and the actual contracting process.

13 How GopherWood Lawyers can assist

GopherWood Lawyers can assist with disputes about unfair terms, threatened enforcement and the consequences of contract changes. Our consumer law and contract disputes services address the agreement, supporting evidence and available relief.

Businesses responding to regulatory enquiries can also seek assistance with ACCC investigations and proceedings, including identifying relevant contracts and responding to concerns about their use.

Call 02 9160 2157 or contact GopherWood Lawyers to discuss your legal options.

This article provides general information about Australian law as at 20 November 2026. It is not legal advice. Contract wording, transaction dates, business eligibility and the way a term is used can change the legal outcome.

14 Sources and further reading

  1. Competition and Consumer Act 2010, Schedule 2
  2. Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001
  3. Treasury Laws Amendment (More Competition, Better Prices) Act 2022
  4. Treasury Laws Amendment (Doubling Penalties for ACCC Enforcement) Act 2026
  5. ASIC: unfair contract term protections for small businesses
  6. ASIC: fines and penalties
  7. ACCC: JJ Richards contract terms declared unfair and void
  8. ACCC: Servcorp business contract terms declared unfair
  9. ACCC: 38 terms in Fuji contracts declared unfair and void
  10. ASIC: CashnGo ordered to pay $3.5 million penalty
  11. ASIC v Auto & General Insurance Company Limited [2025] FCAFC 76
  12. ACCC: Mable amends unfair contract terms