A statutory demand is not an ordinary overdue account reminder. If your company receives a creditor's statutory demand under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), it ordinarily has 21 days after service to comply or make a properly supported court application to set it aside. Missing that deadline can expose the company to a winding up application.

The immediate task is to establish when service occurred, identify what is actually owed and preserve the company's response options. Do not leave the papers with accounts payable while someone tries to resolve the invoice. Directors need to know about the demand straight away.

A letter disputing the debt is not a set aside application. Negotiations do not stop the statutory clock. The application and supporting affidavit must be filed and served within the required period.

Natasha Verma, Associate at GopherWood Lawyers, explains what a statutory demand means, how to respond and what creditors should check before issuing Form 509H. This article addresses companies, rather than bankruptcy procedures against individuals.

01 What is a statutory demand under the Corporations Act?

A statutory demand is a formal written demand served on a company under section 459E of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). It requires payment of a due and payable debt, or an acceptable arrangement to secure or compound it, within the statutory period. Compounding generally involves an agreed compromise rather than simply promising to pay later.

The demand is usually issued by the creditor or its solicitor, not by a court. A creditor does not necessarily need a judgment first. However, the absence of a judgment generally means the demand must be accompanied by a verifying affidavit.

Its significance comes from insolvency law. Under section 459C, failure to comply can establish a rebuttable presumption that the company is insolvent for a subsequent winding up application. Section 459P identifies who may apply, including a creditor. The court can then consider whether to make a winding up order.

This is not an automatic liquidation process. A demand is not a judgment, and expiry of its deadline does not itself appoint a liquidator. Equally, a company with substantial assets cannot safely ignore it. Proving solvency in later proceedings can be expensive, and the opportunity to contest the underlying demand is tightly controlled.

For example, a profitable company might dispute an equipment supplier's invoice because the equipment was never delivered. That dispute needs prompt evidence and a timely response. Saying that the company owns property does not deal with the demand or preserve its right to challenge the invoice.

02 What are the statutory demand requirements and Form 509H rules?

Section 459E permits a demand for one debt, or several debts owed to the same creditor, that are due and payable and reach the statutory minimum. The current ordinary minimum is $4,000. A debt of exactly $4,000 can qualify. A future instalment that has not fallen due should not be treated as an overdue debt without a proper contractual basis.

The current prescription is regulation 5.4.01AAA of the Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth), not regulation 5.4.01AA. The operative minimum and response period for present-day demands are $4,000 and 21 days. Historical temporary restructuring relief provisions in the regulation do not apply to demands served on or after 1 August 2021.

What must the demand contain?

  • Identification of the debt and its amount, or the total of multiple debts.
  • A requirement to pay, secure or compound the amount to the creditor's reasonable satisfaction within the statutory period.
  • The prescribed written form, Form 509H, signed by or on behalf of the creditor.
  • Accurate company and creditor details and the required information about responding to the demand.

Use the current prescribed form rather than an old precedent downloaded from an unrelated matter. Check the company's ACN, not just its trading name. A business name is not necessarily the entity that entered the contract, and related companies are not interchangeable debtors.

When is a supporting affidavit required?

Unless the debt, or every debt included, is a judgment debt, section 459E(3) requires an accompanying affidavit verifying that the amount is due and payable and complying with the applicable court rules. An invoice attachment is not a substitute. The deponent needs a proper factual basis for the evidence.

Review interest, credits, payments and the contractual payment date before preparing that affidavit. A demand should not inflate the balance with unagreed collection charges or assume that a contested variation has become payable merely because an invoice was issued.

03 How do you set aside a statutory demand within 21 days?

Section 459G requires a company seeking to set aside a statutory demand to apply within the statutory period after service. Within that same period, the company must file its supporting affidavit and serve copies of both the application and affidavit on the person who served the demand.

For ordinary current demands, that means 21 days. It is not enough to lodge an application and arrange service later. Nor is it enough to email a draft affidavit, send a complaint to the creditor or instruct solicitors on the final afternoon without leaving time to complete the required steps.

In David Grant & Co Pty Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation (1995) 184 CLR 265; [1995] HCA 43, the High Court confirmed the strict operation of this time requirement. A company should not assume the court can rescue a late application by extending the section 459G deadline.

What should the company do immediately?

  1. Save the demand, affidavit, envelope, delivery records and original emails with their metadata.
  2. Identify every possible service event, including delivery to the registered office and any earlier electronic service.
  3. Ask a lawyer to calculate the deadline, including any applicable rules about counting days and non-business days.
  4. Collect the contract, invoices, payment records, correspondence and evidence supporting any dispute or cross-claim.
  5. Arrange a witness who can explain the facts and swear or affirm the supporting affidavit promptly.

The affidavit must explain the factual basis of the challenge, not merely assert that money is disputed. Identify the transaction, what went wrong and the documents supporting that account. Do not assume new grounds can simply be introduced after the deadline through a later affidavit.

In NSW, proceedings may be brought in the Supreme Court of NSW or the Federal Court of Australia, subject to jurisdiction and procedural requirements. Court forms, filing arrangements and service steps need attention from the outset. Registry assistance does not replace advice about whether the evidence establishes a ground for relief.

04 What grounds can set aside a creditor's statutory demand?

A genuine dispute about the debt

Section 459H applies where there is a genuine dispute about the existence or amount of the debt. The court is not conducting the final trial of the contract claim. The company must nevertheless show something real, rather than a manufactured disagreement or an unsupported denial.

The Full Court's decision in Spencer Constructions Pty Ltd v G & M Aldridge Pty Ltd [1997] FCA 681 explains the genuine dispute threshold, drawing on Eyota Pty Ltd v Hanave Pty Ltd (1994) 12 ACSR 785. A plausible contention requiring investigation can suffice. The court does not simply accept every assertion, particularly where it is inherently implausible or contradicted by the documents.

Examples might include evidence that the agreed goods were not supplied, an invoice uses the wrong contractual rate, or payment depends on a milestone that has not occurred. A complaint about the creditor's manner, without a connection to liability or amount, is not the same thing.

A genuine offsetting claim

An offsetting claim under section 459H is a genuine claim against the creditor by way of counterclaim, set-off or cross-demand. It need not arise from the same transaction as the demanded debt. It must belong to the debtor company and be against the relevant creditor, not merely another company in the creditor's group.

For illustration, a company might acknowledge an unpaid supply invoice but have a genuine damages claim against that supplier for defective earlier deliveries. The evidence should identify the breach, resulting loss and an intelligible calculation. A director's personal complaint does not become the company's offsetting claim.

The court calculates the substantiated amount after addressing the dispute and qualifying offsetting claims. If that amount is below the statutory minimum, section 459H requires the demand to be set aside. If it remains at least the minimum, the court may vary the demand. Disputing a small component does not necessarily defeat the whole demand.

A defect causing substantial injustice, or another reason

Section 459J allows the court to set aside a demand where a defect would cause substantial injustice unless it were set aside, or where there is some other reason to do so. A typographical error is not automatically decisive. The nature of the defect and its practical consequences matter.

Problems with an accompanying affidavit, misleading conduct or misuse of the insolvency procedure may require consideration under the other-reason ground. These arguments are fact-sensitive. Even where the demand appears defective, obtain advice and protect the deadline rather than treating it as a nullity without further action.

05 Can a statutory demand be served by email?

Yes, electronic service can be effective, but not every email establishes valid service. Section 109X permits service on a company by leaving a document at, or posting it to, its registered office. It also permits personal delivery to a director who resides in Australia or an external Territory. These are not the only potentially effective methods.

The current electronic documents framework must also be considered. Sections 110C and 110D extend technology-neutral sending rules to covered documents under Chapter 5, which includes statutory demands. Electronic sending generally requires reasonable accessibility for subsequent reference and transmission to a nominated electronic address.

The Act's definition of nominated electronic address includes an address the recipient has nominated, and can include an address the sender believes on reasonable grounds is current for receiving electronic communications. That is not permission to choose an arbitrary address from an old contact list. Evidence about the address, prior correspondence and accessibility remains important.

Earlier authorities must be read against the legislation that applied when service occurred. In Bioaction Pty Ltd v Ogborne, in the matter of Bioaction Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 436, the Federal Court upheld electronic service of set aside documents under the then-applicable provisions. It concerned the company's response documents, not a universal rule validating every emailed statutory demand.

Do not rely on an old discussion of section 600G without checking the current framework. Conversely, do not assume an emailed demand is ineffective because no paper copy has arrived. There may be several arguable service dates, and the earliest effective service can determine the deadline.

Creditors should preserve the exact attachments, transmission evidence and the basis for selecting the electronic address. Companies should preserve full email headers and alert their lawyers to spam filtering, inaccessible links or damaged attachments. Those facts may matter, but none should be treated as an automatic extension of time.

For paper service, keep the registered office current and arrange reliable handling of mail received by an accountant or registered office provider. A delay in forwarding papers to a director does not necessarily postpone service. Using an accountant's address carries practical responsibilities.

06 Should the company pay, negotiate or apply to set aside?

The right response depends on both the debt and the company's financial position. A solvent company facing a genuinely disputed invoice has different needs from a company that accepts the debt but cannot meet payroll. Assess those questions separately.

Statutory demand response options and timing
ResponseWhen to actMain consideration
Pay the debtBefore the compliance period endsConfirm the correct balance and obtain written confirmation of satisfaction.
Secure or compoundReach an effective arrangement before expiryA proposal alone is not an agreed resolution.
Apply to set asideFile and serve application and affidavit within 21 daysSupport the recognised grounds with evidence.
Consider formal insolvency optionsImmediately if debts cannot be paid when dueEligibility, appointments and effects on proceedings require advice.

The table summarises sections 459E, 459F and 459G. Discussions or an appointment with an adviser do not themselves satisfy a statutory demand.

If payment is appropriate, verify the destination independently to reduce payment fraud risk. Obtain confirmation that the demand has been satisfied. Where only part is paid, do not assume the demand disappears: the balance and statutory consequences still need examination.

If negotiating instalments, document the amount, dates, security, costs and treatment of the demand. An agreement about commercial payment dates is not an extension of the court's section 459G deadline. If the creditor will not provide an effective resolution in time, a protective application may be needed where grounds exist.

Where cash flow problems are broader, ask an insolvency practitioner about small business restructuring, voluntary administration or liquidation. Small business restructuring is available only to eligible companies; voluntary administration involves an external administrator. Neither should be presented as a simple administrative way to erase a demand.

Directors should provide current bank statements, aged creditors and debtors, tax liabilities and a realistic cash flow forecast. Stop relying on hoped-for receipts without checking their timing and collectability. Any formal appointment and its effect on pending or threatened winding up proceedings need coordinated legal and insolvency advice.

07 How long does a statutory demand last, and what happens after 21 days?

There are three different periods to understand: the initial response period, any adjusted compliance period following a timely application, and the period relevant to relying on non-compliance in winding up proceedings. They should not be collapsed into one supposed expiry date.

Under section 459F, a company fails to comply if the demand remains in effect and has not been complied with when the compliance period ends. Where there is a compliant section 459G application, the ordinary compliance period instead ends seven days after that application is finally determined or otherwise disposed of, unless the court orders a different extended period. Read the actual orders carefully.

Section 459C(2)(a) permits reliance on failure occurring during or after the three months ending on the winding up application's filing date. In the usual sequence, a creditor files within three months after non-compliance to rely on that event. This is not three months from issuing the demand, and the hearing need not occur within those three months.

Missing that window does not extinguish the underlying debt. The creditor may need a fresh demand or another proper basis for proceedings. Equally, a debtor cannot assume that doing nothing for three months makes the account disappear.

From winding up application to winding up order

A creditor applying under section 459P must establish the basis for the relief sought. Section 459Q requires particulars of service and non-compliance, attachment of the demand and any variation order, and, unless all relevant debts are judgment debts, a further verifying affidavit complying with the rules.

The applicant must also attend to court procedure, service, notice to ASIC using Form 519 and the applicable publication requirements. Form 519 notifies ASIC of court action; it is not the statutory demand and does not itself wind up the company.

The company may need detailed evidence to rebut presumed insolvency. Section 459S also restricts reliance, without leave, on grounds used or available in a set aside application. Leave requires the ground to be material to proving solvency. Saving the dispute for the winding up hearing is therefore dangerous.

If a winding up order is made, a liquidator takes control of the company's affairs for the liquidation. Paying the petitioning creditor after proceedings start does not necessarily end the case: other creditors and the court's process may remain relevant.

08 How do you issue a statutory demand without misusing the process?

A statutory demand can be appropriate for an undisputed, presently payable corporate debt. It is not a substitute for a trial where liability genuinely needs determination. Before issuing one, read the debtor's complaints rather than assuming they are delay tactics.

Misusing insolvency procedures to pressure payment of a genuinely disputed debt can lead to the demand being set aside and adverse costs orders. In serious cases, abuse of process and indemnity costs may arise. Neither follows automatically from every unsuccessful demand; the conduct and circumstances matter.

A creditor's checklist

  • Confirm the contracting debtor's name, ACN and current registered office.
  • Check that the debt is due, payable and at least $4,000 in aggregate.
  • Reconcile payments, credits, interest and any security or compromise already agreed.
  • Assess correspondence for a genuine dispute or offsetting claim.
  • Use current Form 509H and a proper verifying affidavit where required.
  • Choose a defensible service method and retain evidence of the date and documents served.
  • Record the response deadline and review any application received immediately.
  • Assess whether winding up is commercially sensible if payment does not follow.

Liquidation is a collective process, not a guarantee that the issuing creditor will recover its invoice. Filing expenses, legal costs, liquidator funding and the company's asset position can change the commercial assessment. An ordinary debt claim or negotiated security may produce a better outcome.

Costs also matter to debtor companies. A weak set aside application can leave the company paying its own lawyers and some of the creditor's costs. A successful company does not necessarily recover every dollar spent. Keep settlement proposals realistic and make decisions before urgency drives unnecessary expense.

09 Statutory demand FAQs

Is a creditor's statutory demand a court order?

No. It is a formal demand under section 459E. A winding up order requires court proceedings and a judicial decision. The demand nevertheless creates an urgent deadline with serious consequences.

Can a statutory demand be served by email?

Yes, if the applicable electronic service requirements are met. Check the address, accessibility, attachments and receipt evidence. Do not wait for paper service before seeking advice about an emailed demand.

How long does a statutory demand last?

The ordinary initial compliance period is 21 days after service. A timely set aside application affects that period under section 459F. The three-month presumption window concerns reliance on non-compliance in winding up proceedings, not cancellation of the debt.

Can we get more time because we are negotiating?

Negotiations do not extend the section 459G filing and service deadline. Resolve the demand effectively in writing or protect the company's court response within time if grounds exist. Do not rely on an informal assurance that everything will be sorted out.

What if the company can pay but disputes the invoice?

Solvency is not a reason to ignore the demand. Assemble evidence of the genuine dispute and obtain advice about a timely application under section 459H. Evidence of assets alone does not replace that response.

Can a statutory demand be used against a sole trader?

Not under this corporate procedure. A sole trader is an individual, even when using a business name. Individual debt enforcement and bankruptcy involve different documents and rules.

10 How GopherWood Lawyers can assist

GopherWood Lawyers acts in debt recovery and insolvency disputes. We can assess service, review the debt and supporting evidence, and advise on responding to a demand or pursuing winding up proceedings.

For creditors, our commercial debt recovery advice includes considering whether a statutory demand is appropriate. Directors facing wider financial difficulties can seek advice about director liability and insolvency. Send the complete demand and service records when requesting urgent assistance.

Call 02 9160 2157 or contact GopherWood Lawyers to discuss your legal options.

This article provides general information about Australian law as at 20 November 2026. It is not legal advice. Service dates, contractual terms, available evidence and the company's financial position can change the appropriate response.

11 Sources and further reading

  1. Corporations Act 2001, current register compilation
  2. Corporations Regulations 2001, current register compilation
  3. David Grant & Co Pty Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation [1995] HCA 43
  4. Spencer Constructions Pty Ltd v G & M Aldridge Pty Ltd [1997] FCA 681
  5. Federal Court, winding up proceedings based on an unsatisfied statutory demand
  6. ASIC, Form 519 notification of court action relating to winding up