A serious workplace incident brings an immediate human emergency. Someone may be injured, or worse, and the first priority is always their care and the safety of everyone else on site.

Within hours, however, a second set of obligations begins to run. The law requires the incident to be reported, the scene to be preserved and records to be kept. SafeWork NSW inspectors may attend, take photographs, copy documents and ask to speak with staff. Months later, the same events may be examined in a prosecution of the business, its officers or other parties connected with the site.

What a business does in the first days after an incident often shapes the investigation that follows. This article explains the legal obligations that apply under the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (NSW), the powers SafeWork NSW can use and the decisions that are best made with advice.

01 Is it a notifiable incident?

Under section 35 of the Act, a notifiable incident is the death of a person, a serious injury or illness of a person, or a dangerous incident, arising out of the conduct of a business or undertaking.

A serious injury or illness is defined in section 36. It includes injuries requiring immediate treatment as an in-patient in a hospital, and specified injuries such as amputations, serious head injuries, serious burns, spinal injuries, the loss of a bodily function and serious lacerations.

A dangerous incident under section 37 can be notifiable even if nobody is hurt. It covers incidents that expose a person to a serious risk from an immediate or imminent exposure to things such as an uncontrolled escape of a substance, an uncontrolled fire or explosion, an electric shock, the fall or release from a height of any plant, substance or thing, the collapse of a structure, the collapse or failure of an excavation, and certain failures of plant that requires authorisation.

Whether an incident meets these definitions is sometimes not obvious on the day. Where there is doubt, the safer course is to notify.

02 Reporting to SafeWork NSW

Section 38 requires a person conducting a business or undertaking (a PCBU) to ensure that the regulator is notified immediately after becoming aware that a notifiable incident has occurred. SafeWork NSW receives notifications 24 hours a day on 13 10 50.

If SafeWork NSW asks for written notice, it must be given within 48 hours of the request. The PCBU must also keep a record of each notifiable incident for at least five years from the day notice is given.

Failing to notify is an offence in its own right, separate from any question about how the incident happened. A late or incomplete notification can also colour the regulator's view of the business from the outset.

Other reporting obligations may run at the same time. SafeWork NSW reminds employers that a workplace injury must be notified to the workers compensation insurer within 48 hours of the employer becoming aware of it, and recorded in the register of injuries. Insurance policies, contracts with principals and, for some businesses, other regulators may impose their own notice requirements.

03 Preserving the incident site

Section 39 requires the person with management or control of the workplace to ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, that the site is not disturbed until an inspector arrives or until any earlier time the inspector directs. The site includes any plant, substance, structure or thing associated with the incident.

The obligation does not prevent action to assist an injured person, to remove a deceased person, to make the site safe or minimise the risk of a further notifiable incident, in connection with a police investigation, or where an inspector or the regulator has given permission.

In practice, the person who controls the site is not always the injured worker's employer. A landlord, an owners corporation, a principal contractor or a host business may have management or control of the area where the incident happened. Each should consider its own position.

Preservation also extends beyond the physical scene. Businesses should act quickly to secure CCTV footage before it is overwritten, together with maintenance logs, plant records, risk assessments, safe work method statements, training and induction records, rosters, and emails and messages about the equipment or task involved. Destroying or altering relevant material after an incident can create serious additional legal problems.

04 When inspectors arrive

SafeWork NSW inspectors have broad statutory powers. They can enter a workplace, inspect and examine anything there, take photographs and measurements, take samples, and require a person to provide assistance. Under section 171, an inspector who has entered a workplace can require a person to tell the inspector who has custody of documents, require documents to be produced, and require a person to answer questions.

Separately, section 155 allows the regulator to issue a written notice requiring a person to give information, produce documents or appear before an inspector to give evidence. These notices are often issued in the weeks after an incident, when the investigation is taking shape.

Cooperation matters, and obstructing an inspector is an offence. Cooperation does not, however, mean volunteering everything in an unstructured way. A business is entitled to understand what is being required, from whom and under which power, and to respond accurately and within the scope of the requirement. It is sensible to nominate one person to manage contact with inspectors, keep a record of what is requested and provided, and keep copies of every document handed over.

05 Self-incrimination and legal professional privilege

Section 172 provides that a person is not excused from answering a question or providing information or a document on the ground that it might tend to incriminate them. The section then limits how that material can be used: an answer, information or document provided by an individual is generally not admissible against that individual in civil or criminal proceedings, other than proceedings about its false or misleading nature. Section 173 requires inspectors to warn people of these matters before requiring them to answer.

That protection is for individuals. It does not stop answers given by an employee being used against the business, and a company cannot claim the privilege against self-incrimination.

Section 269 preserves legal professional privilege. Confidential communications made for the dominant purpose of giving or obtaining legal advice, or for use in anticipated proceedings, do not have to be produced. This is one reason the structure of an internal investigation matters. A report commissioned by lawyers to advise on legal exposure may be privileged. A general safety review circulated widely within the business may not be.

06 Employees can be compelled to give evidence

The High Court's decision in Commonwealth of Australia v Helicopter Resources Pty Ltd [2020] HCA 16 illustrates the risk.

A helicopter pilot employed by Helicopter Resources died after falling into a hidden crevasse while working in the Australian Antarctic Territory. A coronial inquest began in the ACT. While it was under way, Helicopter Resources and the Commonwealth were charged with offences under the Commonwealth work health and safety legislation. The company objected to its chief pilot being called to give evidence at the inquest, arguing that his answers could be used as admissions against it in the prosecution.

The High Court unanimously rejected that argument. Compelling the employee to give evidence did not amount to compelling the company to assist in proving the case against it, even though the employee's answers might be admissible against the company.

The case arose from a coronial inquest rather than a SafeWork NSW interview, but the lesson is practical. Employees, supervisors and managers may be required to answer questions about matters central to a later prosecution. They should understand their rights and obligations before they are interviewed, and some may need advice independent of the company's lawyers where their interests could differ.

07 Understanding the risk of prosecution

A serious incident does not, by itself, prove that the law was broken. The central duty in section 19 requires a PCBU to ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, the health and safety of workers and others affected by its work. Section 18 explains what is reasonably practicable by reference to the likelihood of the risk, the degree of harm, what the business knew or ought reasonably to have known, the availability and suitability of ways to eliminate or minimise the risk, and the cost of doing so.

The question is therefore not simply what went wrong. It is whether there were reasonably practicable measures that should have been taken before the incident, and were not.

Other duties sit alongside section 19. Section 20 imposes a duty on a person with management or control of a workplace. Section 27 requires officers, including directors, to exercise due diligence to ensure the business complies with its duties. Workers have their own duties under section 28.

The most serious breaches are prosecuted as Category 1 offences, involving reckless or grossly negligent conduct, or Category 2 offences, where a failure to comply with a duty exposes a person to a risk of death or serious injury or illness. Since 16 September 2024, New South Wales has also had an offence of industrial manslaughter. The NSW Government has stated the maximum penalties as 25 years' imprisonment for an individual and $20 million for a body corporate.

Time limits apply to most work health and safety prosecutions, generally running from the date of the offence or from when it came to the regulator's notice, with special rules for coronial findings and some exceptions. Industrial manslaughter is not subject to the ordinary limitation period.

08 More than one business can be responsible

A fatal incident at an industrial complex at Berkeley, in the Illawarra, shows how widely responsibility can extend.

In June 2020, a vehicle struck and badly damaged a heavy sliding electric gate forming part of the common property of the complex. Over the following days, workers continued to open and close the damaged gate by hand. On 12 June 2020, the gate fell on a worker, causing fatal injuries.

The worker's employer, Maluko Pty Ltd, pleaded guilty to a Category 2 offence. In SafeWork NSW v Maluko Pty Ltd [2023] NSWDC 274, the District Court found a fine of $500,000 appropriate and reduced it by 25 per cent for the early plea, imposing a fine of $375,000. The Court's findings included failures to direct workers not to operate the gate manually, to develop a safe system for using it, and to raise safety concerns with the owners corporation or strata manager.

In SafeWork NSW v The Owners - Strata Plan No 93899 [2024] NSWDC 277, the owners corporation for the site was convicted of breaching its duty as a person with management or control of the workplace and fined $225,000. It had a strata manager with authority to arrange repairs, but that did not remove its own obligation in respect of the damaged gate.

The cases are a reminder that owners, landlords, strata schemes, principal contractors and labour hire hosts can each hold duties for the same risk. Each should obtain its own advice, because their interests in the investigation may not align.

09 Improvement and prohibition notices

Inspectors may issue notices after an incident. Under section 191, an inspector may issue an improvement notice if they reasonably believe a person is contravening a provision of the Act, or has contravened it in circumstances that make it likely the contravention will continue or be repeated. The notice requires the contravention to be remedied by a stated date.

Under section 195, an inspector who reasonably believes that an activity involves, or will involve, a serious risk to health or safety emanating from an immediate or imminent exposure to a hazard may give a direction to stop the activity, and confirm it with a prohibition notice. The activity must not resume until the inspector is satisfied the risk has been remedied.

A business that disagrees with a notice may seek internal review under section 224, but the time limits are short. Under section 228, an application for internal review of an improvement notice generally stays the notice. A prohibition notice continues to operate unless the regulator grants a stay. Non-compliance with a notice is a separate offence.

A notice is not a finding of guilt, but how it is framed and how the business responds can become part of the evidence in any later proceedings. Each notice should be read carefully: the provision said to be contravened, the facts relied on and what is actually required.

10 Fixing the risk without damaging the defence

Businesses should not wait for an investigation to finish before addressing a known risk. Repairs, revised procedures, additional controls and retraining may be required immediately, and continuing exposure to the same hazard can create fresh liability.

Remedial steps should still be planned with care. The site must be released by the inspector or otherwise fall within the exceptions before it is disturbed. Original equipment and records should be retained. Changes should be documented accurately, without speculating about blame in internal emails or reports.

In some cases, a business may be able to offer SafeWork NSW a WHS undertaking under section 216 instead of facing prosecution. An undertaking is a written commitment to specified safety improvements, and it is not available for a Category 1 offence. Whether one is realistic depends on the facts, the business's history and the stage of the investigation.

11 The first 48 hours

  • Provide first aid and emergency care, and make the area safe.
  • Notify SafeWork NSW immediately on 13 10 50 if the incident may be notifiable.
  • Preserve the site, subject to the statutory exceptions, until released by an inspector.
  • Secure CCTV, records, plant and devices before anything is lost or overwritten.
  • Notify the workers compensation insurer and check other policy and contract notice requirements.
  • Nominate one point of contact for inspectors and keep a log of every request.
  • Obtain legal advice before responding to a section 155 notice or arranging staff interviews.
  • Consider whether officers or employees need separate advice.
  • Look after affected workers and families, and arrange support for witnesses.

12 How GopherWood Lawyers can help

A serious workplace incident requires a business to deal with a human crisis while protecting its legal position. Those tasks are not in conflict, but they need to be coordinated from the start.

GopherWood Lawyers acts for businesses, directors and other officers in SafeWork NSW investigations. We advise on notification and site obligations, respond to section 155 notices and inspector requirements, structure privileged internal investigations, prepare people for interviews, seek review of improvement and prohibition notices, negotiate WHS undertakings and defend work health and safety prosecutions.

If your business has experienced a serious incident, or has been contacted by SafeWork NSW, early advice can make a material difference to how the investigation unfolds. Call 02 9160 2157 or contact GopherWood Lawyers about your matter.

This article provides general information about the law in New South Wales as at 9 November 2026. It is not legal advice. Obligations and outcomes depend on the facts of each incident.

13 Sources and further reading

  1. Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (NSW): especially ss 18 to 20, 27, 28, 31 to 34C, 35 to 39, 155, 171 to 173, 191, 195, 216, 224, 228, 232 and 269.
  2. SafeWork NSW: Incident notification.
  3. SafeWork NSW: Internal review of inspector and regulator decisions.
  4. NSW Government: industrial manslaughter laws, 20 June 2024.
  5. Australian Government Solicitor: Commonwealth of Australia v Helicopter Resources Pty Ltd [2020] HCA 16.
  6. SafeWork NSW v Maluko Pty Ltd [2023] NSWDC 274.
  7. SafeWork NSW v The Owners - Strata Plan No 93899 [2024] NSWDC 277.