Most people who read about the Dexus costs ruling saw one number: almost $30 million. The more useful numbers sit underneath it. A senior counsel charging $4,000 an hour. Four executives' salaries converted into an hourly rate by a forensic accountant. A public relations retainer of $50,000 a month. A litigation consultant on $3,000 a day. An eleven-volume court book for the argument about costs alone.

On 26 October 2026, Hammerschlag CJ in Eq gave judgment against Dexus Capital Investors Limited (DCIL) for $29,976,747.84 across two decisions, Dexus Capital Investment Services Pty Ltd v Australia Pacific Airports Corporation Limited (No 4) [2026] NSWSC 1330 and (No 5) [2026] NSWSC 1331. The money is payable to Australia Pacific Airports Corporation Limited (APAC), the owner of Melbourne and Launceston airports, and three of its other shareholders.

We have already written about how a data room put the Dexus Bloc's 27.32% stake at risk in The $4.5 Billion Airport Dispute. This article is about the invoice. It goes through the bill item by item: what was claimed, what the Court allowed, what it refused and why, and what that tells anyone who may one day send, receive or argue about a bill of this kind.

The decisions turn on one clause in one shareholders' deed, and they are subject to appeal. But the questions the Court asked are questions that arise in every serious commercial dispute where a contract says the loser pays.

01 What the $30 million was made of

The judgment sets out each claimant's legal costs, excluding GST, in a table. Dexus accepted that every dollar had actually been incurred. Its argument was about how much of that it should have to pay.

Amounts awarded under the indemnity, 26 October 2026 (excluding GST)
Claimant and solicitorsSolicitorsCounselOtherJudgment
APAC: Norton Rose Fulbright and others*$12,778,527.97$3,177,442.55$1,120,104.69$17,076,075.21
IFM: Gilbert + Tobin**$3,141,826.75$2,091,926.49$185,806.45$5,419,559.69
Future Fund: Baker McKenzie$4,549,806.19$1,518,020.90$176,384.75$6,244,211.84
UTA: Ashurst Perkins Coie***$1,083,576.00$110,270.00$43,055.10$1,236,901.10
Total payable by DCIL$29,976,747.84

* APAC's figures combine Norton Rose Fulbright ($16,485,548.88), other external lawyers ($529,439.16) and travel, accommodation and incidentals ($61,087.17). ** IFM's "other" figure includes $30,092 in mediation costs. *** UTA's solicitors' figure includes disbursements. UTA is Utilities of Australia Pty Ltd as trustee for Utilities Trust of Australia. Future Fund refers to The Northern Trust Company and the Future Fund Board of Guardians.

Three things stand out.

Solicitors, not barristers, drove the bill. More than two thirds of the total was solicitors' professional fees. Counsel accounted for less than a quarter. Yet much of the public reaction, and much of Dexus's argument, centred on senior counsel's hourly rates. Even a successful attack on counsel's fees would have moved a comparatively small part of the total.

This was a money judgment, not an order for costs to be assessed later. Each claimant asked for a sum of money under the deed, and the Court said it would get one. That meant no separate costs assessment process was needed to turn the bill into an enforceable sum.

The costs fight was a case in its own right. The court book for the indemnity dispute alone ran to eleven volumes. Two hearing days had been allowed, and the hearing finished in one. The principal case before it had run for eleven days.

02 Three ways to measure a legal bill

The whole dispute came down to which measuring stick applied. In NSW there are, broadly, three.

The ordinary basis

Costs are in the Court's discretion under section 98 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), and most costs orders are made on the ordinary basis. This is the conventional measure, and it rarely matches what the winner actually paid. A costs assessor allows what was reasonably necessary, at reasonable rates, and the gap between the invoice and the recovery can be substantial.

The indemnity basis

Rule 42.5 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) provides that, when costs are ordered on the indemnity basis, all costs are allowed other than those that "appear to have been unreasonably incurred or appear to be of an unreasonable amount". That is more generous than the ordinary basis, but a costs assessor still decides what was reasonable.

A contractual indemnity

Clause 12.4 of the APAC shareholders' deed says the Defaulting Shareholder "indemnifies each other Shareholder and the Company against any actions, costs, claims, demands, losses, damages or other liabilities to which they may become liable arising out of or in connection with the default of the Defaulting Shareholder".

Dexus accepted that it had to pay the claimants' costs on the indemnity basis. Its case was that clause 12.4 went no further than that. Either the words should be read that way, or a term should be implied, so that the clause covered only amounts "not unreasonably incurred" and "not unreasonable in amount", borrowing the language of rule 42.5.

The Chief Judge in Equity rejected both arguments:

  • The test is connection, not reasonableness. The clause asks whether a liability arose out of or in connection with the default. That is an objective test. The indemnity "is intended to give full protection to the non-defaulting shareholders".
  • There is no discretion. "If the amount claimed falls within the words of the Indemnity it is claimable. There is no discretion to be exercised." An evaluative judgment may be needed about whether the connection exists, but that is a different exercise from deciding what is fair.
  • No reasonableness term would be implied. Applying Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority (NSW) (1982) 149 CLR 337, a reasonableness limit was not necessary to make the indemnity work and was inconsistent with its express words.

"Arising out of" and "in connection with" are wide expressions, but the Court noted they are not unlimited and take their meaning from context, citing Re Khazaal (2012) 246 CLR 601. That limit is where every item the Court refused fell away, as the sections below explain.

The question was never whether the bill was reasonable. It was whether the bill was connected with the default.

The outer edge

The judgment does not hand indemnified parties a blank cheque. The Court accepted there is a point at which an amount is so excessive that it no longer arises from the default but from a claimant's own decision to take on an expense "which is beyond the pale". Unreasonableness may be relevant to whether that line has been crossed, though the Court described it as "not a bright one". A grossly excessive claim might also breach clause 20 of the deed, under which the shareholders promise to be just and faithful to one another.

That was not argued here, and the Court said it was not this case, "even in relation to a senior counsel's rate of $4,000 per hour".

03 The $1,500 an hour argument

Dexus's evidence on quantum came from a solicitor who practises in legal costing. Her report referred to a guideline issued by the NSW Costs Assessment Rules Committee, updated in 2023, which sets out ranges of hourly rates used by costs assessors and widely relied on by parties.

The report disclosed what the claimants' senior counsel charged. Daily court rates appeared to be based on ten hours at the hourly rate. Several exceeded $15,000 a day. The highest rate for a senior counsel who appeared for a claimant was $3,000 an hour, or $30,000 a day. One senior counsel who advised but did not appear at the principal hearing charged $4,000 an hour.

The costs evidence was that, in the author's experience, senior counsel's fees above $1,500 an hour and $15,000 a day are not allowed even on the indemnity basis, and that counsel's fees are usually reduced by a further 5% to 15%. Dexus adopted that position and nothing else. It accepted that its case on counsel was binary: $15,000 a day or less was reasonable, and anything above it was not.

Once the Court held that reasonableness was not the test, that binary position left nothing to fall back on. Dexus had not put an alternative case that particular fees were so extreme they had lost their connection with the default.

The question nobody asked Dexus

The most quoted part of the judgment explains why the Court was unmoved by the size of the fees:

"An onlooker with no experience of the complexity of this type of litigation, the labour intensiveness of dealing with it, the stakes, both commercial and reputational, involved and the expertise needed to deal with it properly, might regard the costs as somewhat jaw-dropping. However, a party dealing with it is entitled to want the highest quality of representation. This does not come cheap."

The next paragraph is the one litigators will remember: "I have little doubt that in bringing the case, Dexus itself briefed counsel whose charges are in the range of those charged by most of those briefed by the Claimants. Dexus did not disclose them."

That observation did not decide the case, because the construction of the clause did. But it is a practical warning for any party that challenges an opponent's legal costs. If you say a rate is excessive while your own counsel charge something similar, expect the court to notice. Where it is open to do so, consider whether your own fees should be in evidence, and be prepared to explain any difference.

04 Duplication, and the right to run your own defence

The costs evidence proposed across-the-board reductions to solicitors' fees, largely to reflect duplication across large legal teams. It suggested 20% off APAC's solicitors' fees, 35% off IFM's and 20% off the Future Fund's. In the separate UTA decision it suggested 10% off solicitors' fees and 15% off counsel's fees.

The Court rejected those reductions on several grounds.

  • Actual duplication was not proved. A percentage drawn from experience is not evidence that particular work was done twice.
  • Some duplication is inevitable. A lawyer who knows how these cases work would recognise duplication as a consequence of the multi-party, multi-issue nature of the case. The Court added that, in some instances, "duplication may be a safeguard".
  • In UTA's case, counsel's fees "look modest". There was no justification for reducing them. The Court did accept that UTA's solicitors' fees "may be on the high side", especially as no client discount had been given, but they were still connected with the default.

"You should have let APAC run it"

Dexus also argued that IFM and the Future Fund should have done what UTA did, which was to leave the defence of the claim largely to APAC. The argument has an obvious appeal for any party facing several sets of opposing lawyers on the same side of the record.

The Court rejected it. UTA's choice was its own. Unlike UTA, IFM and the Future Fund had board representatives "whose conduct, and in some cases their integrity, was being attacked". Given the nature of the case, they "could not have been expected not to fight it to the full extent of their capabilities and resources".

The lesson cuts both ways. If your case attacks the conduct or integrity of individual directors, every party connected with those directors has a real interest in separate representation, and you may end up paying for all of it. Before pleading that kind of case, the cost of opposing several fully resourced teams should be part of the decision.

05 Your own people's time is not a cost

APAC and IFM each claimed the value of time their own executives spent on the litigation.

  • APAC claimed $215,475.50 for four executives. A forensic accountant took their salaries, converted them to an hourly value and multiplied that by the hours said to have been spent on the case.
  • IFM claimed $700,438 in "Staff Costs" for three senior people, including a director, that director's alternate and a senior in-house legal executive. The figure was a retrospective estimate prepared by an unidentified person.

Both claims failed. The Court said these people "were full-time employees who were doing their job, for which they were paid salaries, which they would have been paid anyway". Neither APAC nor IFM showed that the work caused it to lose an opportunity or other benefit, or to incur any cost on top of those salaries. The Court referred to PND Civil Group Pty Ltd v Bastow Civil Constructions Pty Ltd [2017] NSWCA 159 at [70] to [71].

The evidence would not have been enough in any event. No contemporaneous record of the time had been kept, and the Court said it would not have relied on the estimates.

What this means for in-house teams

Many businesses assume the hours their executives lose to a dispute can be added to the bill. This decision shows why that assumption is unsafe, even under an indemnity this wide. A salary that would have been paid anyway is not a loss caused by the dispute. To have any prospect of recovering management time, a business generally needs to show something more: work it could not do, revenue it lost, a temporary hire it had to make or overtime it had to pay, supported by records kept at the time.

If a contract is meant to cover internal time, it should say so expressly and explain how that time will be valued.

06 The PR retainer the Court called a luxury

By a letter agreement dated 2 May 2025, countersigned on 13 May 2025, APAC retained the corporate advisory firm Bespoke Approach on a month-to-month retainer of $50,000. The retainer was paid until 17 November 2025, after which it dropped to $25,000 a month, with a blended fee of $35,500 for November 2025. The engagement letter described advice to management and the board on dealing with stakeholders including governments, media, airlines and customers. APAC claimed $489,551.66.

The claim failed for want of evidence. The material did not reveal "what precisely, if anything, Bespoke did, the time it spent, or any benefits it gave APAC". The Court accepted that APAC was free to spend its money as it wished. But the retainer "no doubt represented the cost of having Bespoke on tap, irrespective of whether it was needed or what it did". This "prophylactic cost, even if it was commercially sensible (about which I express no opinion), was a luxury", and not one that could fairly be said to arise out of or in connection with the default.

The litigation consultant

APAC also claimed $702,369.30 for a litigation consultant engaged in June 2025 by a related entity, on $3,000 a day plus expenses, a phone and parking, to coordinate the litigation day to day. The consultant later became APAC's Interim General Counsel and Company Secretary. The claim was abandoned during submissions. The Court said the abandonment was correct "for a number of reasons", without needing to go into them.

The lesson for anyone hiring advisers during a dispute

Communications advice during a high-profile dispute can be valuable. The problem here was not the decision to retain advisers. It was the absence of evidence linking what they did to the dispute. If you may later seek to recover the cost of advisers other than lawyers:

  • Define the scope of the engagement by reference to the dispute, not general stakeholder management.
  • Ask for invoices that describe the work actually done and the time spent on it.
  • Keep a record of why each piece of work was needed because of the dispute.
  • Be cautious with standing retainers paid whether or not any work is done.

07 Paying for the argument about the bill

Arguing about costs costs money. The Court held that the claimants' costs of the indemnity hearing were themselves recoverable under clause 12.4, to the extent they arose out of or in connection with the default. Costs spent pursuing an amount that was disallowed would not meet that test.

Rather than invite a further round of litigation over those costs, the Court made a provisional order that DCIL pay, on the indemnity basis:

  • all of the Future Fund's costs of the indemnity proceedings; and
  • 80% of APAC's and IFM's costs, with the Court applying a 20% discount to cover the amounts that had been disallowed.

The order was to take effect after seven days unless a party objected in writing. If it took effect, it would replace any further claim under the indemnity for those costs. The Court described a further suit on the indemnity as "a regrettable eventuality" and said the order would bring the proceedings "to a long overdue conclusion".

The 20% discount is a reminder that weak items of claim carry a price beyond their own value. The claims for executive time and the retainer did not just fail on their own terms. They led the Court to discount APAC's and IFM's recovery of the costs of the argument itself.

"Nothing of value was added"

UTA's claim was dealt with separately. The Court had been told that Dexus and UTA had settled in principle. On the day of judgment, after the Court indicated it was almost ready to rule on the other claims, it was told they had not settled and was asked to relist UTA's claim. The Court relisted it straight away and gave judgment for the full $1,236,901.10 that day. Its assessment of the exercise was brief: "Nothing of value was added by the relisting."

08 Which Dexus entity pays, and for what

The Dexus Bloc was not one company. Its members held interests through different trustee entities, and that structure carried through to the costs orders.

  • DCIL, the Defaulting Shareholder, bears the money judgments under the indemnity and the provisional order for the costs of the indemnity hearing.
  • Dexus Capital Investment Services Pty Ltd and InfraBridge (GIF Cayman Holdco) 4, L.P., the other unsuccessful plaintiffs, were ordered to pay the claimants' costs of the proceedings on the ordinary basis, but only so far as those costs are not covered by the money judgments, so that there is no double recovery.
  • TCorp's claim of $7.4 million was resolved with Dexus before judgment. Dexus disclosed that the final terms were being finalised and that, if they were not, TCorp may ask the Court to determine its claim. The $7.4 million is the amount claimed, not a court award or a confirmed settlement figure.

The Court also declined to make the declarations the claimants had sought, finding them of no utility. Each claimant asked for a money judgment and received one.

Dexus has disclosed that the estimated total of these amounts was reflected within approximately $60 million of costs expensed in its FY26 accounts. That is an accounting figure. It is not a further award.

For corporate groups, the structure matters. A contractual indemnity attaches to the party that gave it, here the Defaulting Shareholder. Related entities that joined the litigation but were not the Defaulting Shareholder faced ordinary costs orders instead. Before a group starts proceedings, it should know which entity carries which exposure, and whether the plaintiffs it names will bring a contractual indemnity into play.

09 If you are negotiating an indemnity now

The result in Dexus follows from the particular words of clause 12.4. A differently worded clause can produce a very different outcome. That makes the drafting stage the cheapest point at which to decide how a future bill will be measured.

If you may one day be the party paying

  • Write the measure into the clause. If you want recovery limited to costs that are reasonably incurred and reasonable in amount, say so expressly. The Court would not imply that limit here.
  • Consider a cap or a link to court-assessed costs. A clause can limit legal costs to those recoverable on the indemnity basis, or to a fixed amount.
  • Exclude what you do not intend to fund. Internal management time, public relations, lobbying and consultants can be excluded or capped by name.
  • Look at "in connection with". It is one of the widest connecting phrases in commercial drafting. Narrower language changes the reach of the clause.

If you may one day be the party recovering

  • Keep the clause broad, and keep the evidence. A wide indemnity still requires proof of connection. Keep invoices and retainers that show what was done and why.
  • Record internal time as it happens, and record any additional cost, lost opportunity or temporary resourcing, if you may seek to recover it.
  • Do not pad the claim. Weak items can reduce the recovery of the costs of the argument, as the 20% discount here shows.

If you are already in a dispute under an indemnity

  • Check the indemnity before deciding whether to issue or defend proceedings. Your exposure may be measured by your opponent's actual invoices, not a costs assessor's view of them.
  • If you intend to challenge the amount, run arguments about connection and scope, not only reasonableness, and consider an alternative position rather than a single cap.
  • Think carefully before pleading a case that attacks the integrity of individual directors. It can multiply the number of fully resourced opponents whose costs you may have to pay.
  • If settlement of the costs claim is possible, settle it properly and promptly. A settlement in principle that falls over on the day of judgment helps no one.

10 What happens next

The appeals from the May 2026 decision, brought by REST Infrastructure Trust and the remaining Dexus Bloc shareholders, are listed in the NSW Court of Appeal from 30 November to 2 December 2026, with an additional day available if required. Dexus told the market on 27 October 2026 that any appeal against the costs and indemnity orders may be heard together with those appeals. Trade press reported on 9 November 2026 that Dexus intends to challenge the costs orders as part of its appeal.

If the principal decision were overturned, the foundation for the indemnity claims would be in question. If it stands, the October decisions are likely to be cited whenever a party argues that a broadly worded contractual indemnity should be read down to the standard of a costs assessment. Either way, the Court of Appeal may have the last word on both.

11 How GopherWood Lawyers can assist

GopherWood Lawyers acts for companies, shareholders, directors and investors in shareholder and commercial disputes, including disputes over default notices, indemnities and the recovery of legal costs. We can review an indemnity before a transaction or proceedings begin, assess the costs exposure on both sides of a dispute, and prepare or answer a claim under a costs indemnity.

If a shareholder dispute or an indemnity claim may be coming, speak with our team.

12 Sources and case status

Reviewed as at 16 November 2026. The principal decision and the costs decisions are subject to appeal, and the position may change. Quotations are from the judgments. This article is general information, not legal advice about any particular dispute or contract.

  1. Dexus Capital Investment Services Pty Ltd v Australia Pacific Airports Corporation Limited (No 4) [2026] NSWSC 1330, 26 October 2026: construction of clause 12.4, the costs tables, the refused claims and the orders for APAC, IFM and the Future Fund.
  2. Dexus Capital Investment Services Pty Ltd v Australia Pacific Airports Corporation Limited (No 5) [2026] NSWSC 1331, 26 October 2026: UTA's claim and orders.
  3. Dexus Capital Investment Services Pty Ltd v Australia Pacific Airports Corporation Limited [2026] NSWSC 600, 29 May 2026: the principal decision upholding APAC's default notice.
  4. Dexus, ASX release, "Update on APAC matter", 27 October 2026: summary of the orders, the TCorp claim, the FY26 expense and the appeal listing.
  5. Dexus Core Infrastructure Fund, APAC update, 7 September 2026: appeal hearing dates.
  6. Lawyerly, "Dexus to challenge $30M costs as part of APAC shareholder breach appeal", 9 November 2026: trade press report of the intended costs appeal.
  7. Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) s 98 and Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) r 42.5: the Court's costs discretion and the indemnity basis of costs.